Menu Home Search

Somerset LMC Unfunded Work Survey

Updated on Monday, 5 October 2015, 1289 views

Introduction

The work that General Practices are being asked to do on behalf of other organisations has increased significantly over the last few years, and this cannot continue without some recognition of, and funding for, such work.  One difficulty has been quantifying the size of the problem, but certainly the steady increase means that the pre and post op Enhanced service (ES) negotiated in 2004 has long outlived its usefulness in this respect and needs re-visiting.  In 2010, the LMC presented evidence to Somerset PCT that healthcare assistant and phlebotomist work done in Practices for other organisations had far exceeded the 10% above baseline agreed in the ES.  In 2014 a further study quantified this as being between 25-30% of the total work done by practice HCAs and nurses.  In addition, GPs are increasingly being asked to take on various tasks that previously have been done by clinicians in other organisation, with a recent personal study giving a figure of 27% of communications from secondary care providers to practices   requiring one, two, or even three subsequent GP actions.

Somerset LMC has persistently told commissioners that this unfunded transfer of work cannot continue , and to support our case  further we  recently invited practices to take part in a survey  to  determine the nature and quantity of the non-commissioned tasks they were being asked to perform.  The GPC   released a document in January 2015 which reinforces the approach of Somerset LMC.  (LINK)

Practices were asked to fill in and return a standard proforma asking about the nature and number of tasks that they did during   January 2015 that were on behalf of other organisations, unfunded, and outside a GMS or ES contract.

Results

14 Practices returned forms.  Not all clinicians in all participating practices took part, but all areas of Somerset were covered.  These results are therefore qualitative, and represent only a small proportion of the actual number of tasks expected of GPs in the month under consideration.

The results were categorised as follows:-

Blood test on behalf of another organisation  52 
Med Cert that should have been dealt with elsewhere    5
Request for out-patient urgent prescription 19 
Letter requesting GP follow up investigations done elsewhere 21
Inappropriate re-referral request   27
Other 53
TOTAL 117

                                        

There were many additional comments made (see attached list). These relate mainly to the category ‘other’ and they reveal work not counted above, which when added to the total adds up to  a final total of 198 such tasks.   This is an average of 14 per Practice.

The LMC evaluated the category ‘other’ and classified the requests into broad groups and the results are as follows:-

Re or onward referral for related condition   20
Follow up investigations done elsewhere 17
Prescriptions that should have been done elsewhere  12
Blood test request  11
Pre and post op care  8
Miscellaneous  8
Admin tasks 7
ECG requests 6
Pharmacy referral   2
Dental 1
Examination Board letter   1

 

Discussion

The fact that   only 14 out of 75 Practices returned forms  is most likely a reflection of workload pressures rather than a feeling that this matter is not important to GPs . For the same reason there is a degree of under reporting for those Practices that did return forms. We are very grateful to those GPs who managed to contribute.

That said, we do now have a snap shot of the nature of the work transferred and an idea about the proportion of practice work that they may represent.  What is most striking about the figures is that most of the requests under ‘other’ are related to tasks that clearly remain under the contractual remit of the other organisation, e.g. onward referrals for related conditions, follow up of investigations and prescribing. This is supported by the initial results table which also demonstrates that by far the largest transfer of work is phlebotomy.

Suggested Next Steps

The Commissioners need to work with the LMC to ensure that other organisations fulfil their contractual obligations
To facilitate this Somerset LMC would suggest that Practices use the attached proformas – based on those suggested by the GPC - to send back inappropriate requests to the submitting organisation, whenever this is practical and not detrimental to the patient. You may choose to use the form to inform the organisation that the practice  has complete the task requested on this occasion,  but will not do so in the future.
The LMC and CCG have already started to negotiate on developing a new form of ES to address the funding of transferred work and we hope that this document will help  with that development

Template

Comments from survey

 

Related guidance...

The Case for Funding Primary Care for work transferred from other agencies

Background - Structure of General Practice General Practitioners are self-employed. Their Practice is a business. GP services are...

Somerset LMC Weekly update Friday 1st April 2016

All Somerset GPs and Practice Managers Somerset Together 'Option C' Managing workload GP Responsibility for Diagnostic Tests Undertaken...

Somerset LMC Weekly Update Friday 21st July 2017

All Somerset GPs and Practice Managers This and Previous updates can be found here Sounds of Summer The latest...

Somerset LMC Weekly Update Friday 15 January 2016

Sent to all Somerset GPs, Practice Managers and Lead Nurses This and previous updates are available here Investing in Primary...

Somerset LMC Weekly Update Friday 2nd September 2016

All Somerset GPs and Practice Managers This and previous updates can be found here Its been fun,...

Somerset LMC Weekly Update Friday 14th September 2018

All Somerset GPs and Practice Managers This and previous updates can be found here Hearts and Minds the latest blog from LMC Chairman...

Quality First:Managing workload to deliver safe patient care

GPs and practices are under unprecedented pressure. There are about 340 million consultations annually in general practice in England,...

Somerset LMC Weekly Update Friday 29th January 2016

Sent to all Somerset GPs and Practice Managers This and Previous updates can be found here Are you worried that...

Somerset LMC Weekly Update Friday 23rd June 2017

All Somerset GPs and Practice Managers Rock and A Hard Place: latest Blog from LMC Chairman Nick Bray LMC Position Paper on the...

Somerset LMC Weekly Update Friday 11th March 2016

All Somerset GPs and Practice Managers This and previous updates can be found here SPQS Somerset Together Releasing...