ࡱ > - / ( ) * + , @ & bjbjqq . & ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 8 7 L @ " 8 8 8 8 8 8 $ R ճ ܮ ~ G 8 8 G G ܮ ~ ~ 8 8 G G G G ~ 8 ~ 8 G G G G " ~ ~ 8 p
q I ` 4 0 7
O ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 8 h G 2 T 8 8 8 ܮ ܮ D ֡ " 1 ֡
GPC Media Coverage and Parliamentary Report
BMA mentions in national press / TV & Radio
March 2008
Introduction
With the GP poll result, the National Audit Office report on the new GMS contract, and the winning outcome of the Judicial Review on pensions, there has been a great deal of coverage in both the national and regional press. GPs appeared in a staggering 307 broadcasts.
In a landmark judgment, the BMA won its case against the governments action in reneging on its decision on how GPs pensions would be calculated from the years 2004 - 06. The BMA called on the government to now pay GPs the pensions they have worked and paid for.
When the NAO report on the new GMS was published, GPC members defended the work that GPs do in the face of press stories about less work for more pay. The BMAs GP poll of opinion showed that 98 out of every 100 GPs believed that the governments method of negotiation was unacceptable.
Press Releases
4/2/08 BMA response to the Health Secretarys letter to all GPs
4/2/08 BMA response to the Health Secretarys letter to all GPs
12/2/08 BMA announces date of the GP poll of opinion
14/2/08 General Practitioners Committee seeks grass roots GPs for regional representative roles
19/2/08 BMA releases GP poll questions
18/2/08 Employers need to do more for staff returning to work after ill-health, says BMA
18/2/08 Briefing note: GPs, sick notes and incapacity benefit
28/2/08 Patients are benefiting from the new GP contract
6/3/08 BMA announces GP poll results
11/3/08 Government in court for Judicial Review over cap on GPs pensions
13/3/08 Landmark ruling for BMA : Association wins case over GPs pensions
17/3/08 Review of sickness scheme is long overdue, says BMA
Letters to Press from GPs include the following:
DateSignatoryPublicationSubject of letter5/2/08Dr Laurence BuckmanIndependentGP contract6/2/08Dr Richard VautreyYorkshire Evening PostGPs service to patients14/2/08Dr Richard VautreyHealth Service JournalExtended hours26/2/08Dr Hamish MeldrumSunday TimesBMA HQ licence extension26/2/08Dr Andrew DeardenDaily MailPensions27/2/08Dr Laurence BuckmanPulseQOF28/2/08Dr Laurence BuckmanDaily MirrorGP Pay28/2/08Dr Laurence BuckmanMetro (London)GP contract28/2/08Dr Laurence BuckmanDaily MailGP Pay28/2/08Dr John CanningGuardianNAO report on GP Pay28/2/08Dr Hamish MeldrumThe PeopleBMA HQ licence extension28/2/08Dr John CanningThe GuardianNAO report on GP contract11/3/08Dr Tony StantonThe GuardianPolyclinics
GP media coverage report
March 2008
NationalRegionalTotalPrint:64190254Broadcasts:58249307
SUBJECTNational
broadcastNational printNAO report / GP contract157Sick notes / incapacity benefit85Extended hours2538Polyclinics88Catching up with cancer campaign1-Breaches in patient confidentiality1-Surgeries in supermarkets-1GP pay-1PCTs assessing surgeries QoF performances-1Prescribing drug brands-1NHS treating overseas patients-1Government funding of the NHS-1TOTAL5864
BMA spokespeopleBroadcastPrintLaurence Buckman1921Richard Vautrey189Chaand Nagpaul81John Canning41Rob Barnett1-Peter Holden 23Hamish Meldrum33Kailash Chand2-Tony Calland1-Peter Fellows-1BMA mentions-25TOTAL5864
BROADCASTS
Thursday, 28 February 2008
NAO report / GP contract
Dr Chaand Nagpaul:
GMTV
BBC1 Breakfast News
BBC 1 '6 o'clock news'
Dr Laurence Buckman:
BBC 1 '1 o'clock news'
BBC 1 Breakfast News
BBC News 24
BBC Radio 2 Wake up to Wogan
BBC Radio 4 Today programme
BBC Radio 5 Live Breakfast
Channel 5 News
Sky News
Dr Richard Vautrey:
Channel 4 Lunchtime News
PA Multimedia
Dr John Canning:
IRN
Dr Rob Barnett:
BBC 1 '6 o'clock news'
Wednesday, 20 February 2008
Sicknotes
Dr John Canning:
BBC Radio 4 Today programme
Sky News
BBC Radio 5 Live
Dr Richard Vautrey:
ITN
Dr Peter Holden:
BBC 1 Breakfast News
BBC News 24
Tuesday, 19 February 2008
GP Poll extended hours
Dr Laurence Buckman:
BBC Radio 5 Live
Dr Hamish Meldrum:
Sky TV
Dr Kailash Chand:
Sky TV
Saturday, 16 February 2008
Polyclinics
Dr Laurence Buckman:
BBC 1 Breakfast News
Dr Richard Vautrey:
BBC Radio 4 Today programme
BBC Radio 5 Live
BBC News 24
BBC Radio 4 6 o'clock news
BBC Radio 4 10 o'clock news
BBC Radio 4 Saturday PM
Dr Laurence Buckman:
BBC 1 10 o'clock news
Saturday, 9 February 2008
Extended hours
Dr Hamish Meldrum:
BBC Radio 4 Today programme
Friday, 8 February 2008
Extended hours
Dr Laurence Buckman:
BBC Radio 4 6 o'clock news'
BBC Radio 5 Live Drivetime
Thursday, 7 February 2008
Extended hours
Dr Laurence Buckman:
BBC Radio 5 Live
Wednesday, 6 February 2008
Richard Hortons letter to The Times
Dr Hamish Meldrum:
BBC Radio 4 Today programme
Tuesday, 5 February 2008
Extended hours
Dr Chaand Nagpaul:
BBC Radio 4 News
Catching up with Cancer
Dr Laurence Buckman:
BBC Radio 4 News
Monday, 4 February 2008
Extended surgery hours
Dr Laurence Buckman:
BBC 1 Breakfast News
ITN
BBC Radio 4 Today programme
BBC News 24
Dr Richard Vautrey:
GMTV
BBC Radio 4 Today programme
BBC Radio 5 Live
IRN
BBC 1 '1 o'clock news'
Channel 4 Evening News
BBC 1 Six o'clock News
Dr Chaand Nagpaul:
BBC 1 Breakfast News
Channel 4 Lunchtime News
BBC News 24
BBC Radio 4 Six o'clock News
Dr Kailash Chand:
ITV Lunchtime News
Breaches of confidentiality
Dr Tony Calland:
BBC Radio 4 PM programme
Saturday, 2 February 2008
Incapacity benefit
Dr Richard Vautrey
BBC Radio 4 PM programme
BBC News 24
NATIONAL PRESS CUTTINGS
28/02
The Times P.4 HYPERLINK "http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/life_and_style/health/article3449057.ece" Contract was a windfall for GPs but not a good deal for patients
(quote by Laurence Buckman)
Daily Mirror P.14 HYPERLINK "http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/topstories/2008/02/28/doctor-dolittle-89520-20334009/" Doctor Dolittle (quote by Laurence Buckman)
Daily Mirror P.8 Editorial: GP hours a sick joke
Daily Mail P.19 HYPERLINK "http://www.dailymail.co.uk/pages/live/articles/news/news.html?in_article_id=521428&in_page_id=1770" GPs do get more pay for doing less (quote by Laurence Buckman)
Guardian P.2 HYPERLINK "http://www.guardian.co.uk/society/2008/feb/28/health.nhs" GP practices earning 58& more for 5% less work, audit office finds
(quote by Laurence Buckman)
Independent P.17 HYPERLINK "http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/blunder-on-gps-pay-cost-163176bn-788576.html" Blunder on GPs pay cost 1.7bn (quote by Laurence Buckman)
Daily Express P.2 NHS suffers as GPs pay costs 1.7bn too much
23/02
The Times P.4 HYPERLINK "http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/life_and_style/health/article3419856.ece" GPs are at odds with patients over surgery opening hours
The Times P.4 HYPERLINK "http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/life_and_style/health/article3419862.ece" Analysis: A fight ministers know they can win
22/02
The Times P.51 Feeling unwell? Just pop down to the supermarket to see the GP
21/02
Daily Mirror P.27 Well out of order. Fury as health chief tells GPs to stamp out sick-note culture.
(quote by Peter Holden)
The Times P.8 Well note scheme reform
20/02
Independent HYPERLINK "http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/johnson-tackles-sick-note-culture-784505.html" Johnson tackles sick note culture (quote by John Canning)
Evening Standard P.11 GPs told to fight sick note culture (quote by Peter Holden)
19/02
The Times P.17 HYPERLINK "http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/comment/columnists/david_aaronovitch/article3393128.ece" Ignore the doctors. Polyclinics are the future (quote by Richard Vautrey)
Daily Telegraph P.23 HYPERLINK "http://www.telegraph.co.uk/opinion/main.jhtml?xml=/opinion/2008/02/19/dl1902.xml" Editorial: What GPs cant do about incapacity benefit
The Times P.2 Extended hours (quote by Laurence Buckman)
17/02
The People P.4 Scrap docs clinics says health chief (quote by Hamish Meldrum)
The People P.22 Q & A with Hamish Meldrum
Observer P.12 GPs leader hits out at plans for Soviet-style polyclinics
(quote by Richard Vautrey)
Sunday Mirror P.7 Attack onone-stop Dr shops (quote by Richard Vautrey)
The Sunday Times P.2 Doctors reject polyclinics plan (quote by Richard Vautrey)
News of the World P.2 GP clinic plan fury (quote by Richard Vautrey)
Independent on Sunday P.7 Doctors leader warns against super-surgeries
(quote by Richard Vautrey)
Sunday Telegraph P.29 Richard Horton: Luckily, GPs are wiser than their leaders
Sunday Express P.20 Polyclinics plan will leave GPs in tatters (quote by Richard Vautrey)
12/02
Independent P.34 HYPERLINK "http://www.independent.co.uk/opinion/letters/letters-mps-expenses-781049.html" Ministers were warned on GP pay - Letter from Laurence Buckman
The Times P.4 HYPERLINK "http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/life_and_style/career_and_jobs/public_sector/article3349261.ece" Face not fit? PCTs are taking a tougher stance when assessing QoF performances
(quote by Richard Vautrey)
The Times P.4 GPs bribed to switch pills (quote by Peter Fellows)
10/02
Sunday Telegraph P.6 HYPERLINK "http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/main.jhtml?xml=/news/2008/02/10/ngps110.xml" Majority of GPs against plan to work extra hours
Independent on Sunday P.30 My day on the NHS frontline (doctors working hours)
09/02
Guardian P.6 HYPERLINK "http://www.guardian.co.uk/society/2008/feb/09/health.health" GPs agree to longer opening hours after 12-month row
(quote by Laurence Buckman)
Daily Mail P.15 HYPERLINK "http://www.mailonsunday.co.uk/pages/live/articles/news/news.html?in_article_id=513226&in_page_id=1770" GPs retreat over surgery hours (quote by Laurence Buckman)
Financial Times P.2 Extra GP hours least bad option
Daily Mirror P.5 GPs back down over hours row (quote by Laurence Buckman)
The Times P.2 When Saturday comes Longer hours for doctors (quote by Laurence Buckman)
Daily Telegraph P.2 Deal on GP surgery hours moves closer (Laurence Buckman)
08/02
Evening Standard P.55 Support is what our GPs need
07/02
Evening Standard P.12 We all work anti-social hours why cant GPs too?
Independent P.40 Letters: Browns clash with the GPs
Daily Express P.39 Letters: Should GPs be forced to work longer hours?
06/02
The Times P.16 Letters: Shouting the odds
Daily Mail P.14 HYPERLINK "http://www.dailymail.co.uk/pages/live/articles/columnists/columnists.html?in_article_id=512558&in_page_id=1772&in_author_id=256" So whos really stopping us seeing a GP when we want?
05/02
The Times P.4 HYPERLINK "http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/life_and_style/career_and_jobs/public_sector/article3304089.ece" GPs find no tender mercy (quote by Richard Vautrey)
The Times P.2 Other views Hamish Meldrum quote regarding the Ghanian patient who was refused treatment by the NHS.
The Times P.2 Other views Peter Holden quoted on the governments attitude to the NHS
Independent P.27 HYPERLINK "http://www.independent.co.uk/opinion/commentators/steve-richards/steve-richards-why-alan-johnsons-letter-could-deliver-the-next-election-to-labour-ndash-or-to-the-tories-778042.html" Why Alan Johnsons letter could deliver the next election to Labour or to the Tories
Independent P.28 HYPERLINK "http://www.independent.co.uk/opinion/letters/letters-gps-hours-778044.html" Letters: GP hours dispute is a distraction from the real NHS problems
Independent P.13 HYPERLINK "http://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/health-and-wellbeing/health-news/doctors-are-being-bullied-over-hours-says-bma-778065.html" Doctors are being bullied over hours, says BMA
The Sun P.2 GPs fury at longer hours bid (quote by Laurence Buckman)
Daily Star P.2 Docs rocked (quote by Laurence Buckman)
Daily Mirror P.6 HYPERLINK "http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/topstories/2008/02/05/health-minister-s-ultimatum-to-gps-earning-100-000-89520-20309884/" Work more hoursor take a pay cut (quote by Laurence Buckman)
Financial Times P.4 Johnson in plea to doctors on hours
Daily Express P.7 Labour war on GPs (quote by Chaand Nagpaul)
Daily Mail P.17 HYPERLINK "http://www.dailymail.co.uk/pages/live/articles/health/healthmain.html?in_article_id=512197&in_page_id=1774" Labour takes its plea for longer opening straight to the GPs
(quote by Laurence Buckman)
The Times P.16 Letters: HYPERLINK "http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/comment/letters/article3307191.ece" Harsh words dont help from Richard Horton
Daily Telegraph P.14 Surgery hours row grows as Johnson writes to GPs
(quote by Laurence Buckman)
Daily Telegraph P.1 GPs could quit NHS and charge you 25
Daily Telegraph P.22 HYPERLINK "http://www.telegraph.co.uk/opinion/main.jhtml?xml=/opinion/2008/02/05/do0503.xml" Michael Ingram: A bizarre plan to abolish family doctors
Daily Telegraph P.23 HYPERLINK "http://www.telegraph.co.uk/opinion/main.jhtml?xml=/opinion/2008/02/05/dl0501.xml" Editorial comment: Time to heal the rift on GPs pay and conditions
Guardian P.12 HYPERLINK "http://www.guardian.co.uk/society/2008/feb/05/nhs.health" BMA accuses Johnson of twisting figures in plea to GPs over hours
(quote by Laurence Buckman)
04/02
Evening Standard P.6 Pressure on GPs to open at weekends (quote by Laurence Buckman)
02/02
Daily Telegraph P.65 Are GPs good value for money? (quote by Laurence Buckman)
Daily Telegraph P.29 HYPERLINK "http://www.telegraph.co.uk/opinion/main.jhtml?xml=/opinion/2008/02/02/nosplit/dt0201.xml" Letters: Family doctor service is endangered by changes to GPs contracts (from Laurence Buckman and Mark Porter)
ONLINE NEWS ARTICLES
HYPERLINK "http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/health/7266691.stm" GP contract 'a bad deal for NHS'
BBC Online Thu, 28 Feb 2008: quote by Laurence Buckman
The new GP contract in England has cost the government 1.76bn more than predicted in its first three years but productivity has fallen, says a report.
HYPERLINK "http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/health/7267585.stm" Was the GP contract a bad deal?
BBC Online Thu, 28 Feb 2008: BMA mention
The National Audit Office (NAO) claims it now knows how much ministerial miscalculation was involved in drawing up a new contract with GPs.
HYPERLINK "http://skynews6.typepad.com/my_weblog/2008/02/doctors-polled.html" Doctors Polled On Health Policy
Sky News Wed, 20 Feb 2008: quote by Hamish Meldrum
The BMA is beginning a UK-wide poll of family doctors asking them to choose between the two options regarding extended hours put forward by the Government. It will also ask for their opinion on government health policy and whether they think plans to introduce private providers into general practice will harm patient care.
HYPERLINK "http://c.moreover.com/click/here.pl?z1304924692&z=950241631" Bid to tackle 'sick-note culture'
BBC Online Wed, 20 Feb 2008: quote by Peter Holden
Health secretary Alan Johnson is expected to set out his plans for changing what he calls the sick-note culture into a 'well-note culture'.
HYPERLINK "http://skynews6.typepad.com/my_weblog/2008/02/doctors-polled.html" Doctors Polled On Extended Hours
Sky News - Monday 18 Feb 2008: quote by Hamish Meldrum
The BMA is beginning a UK-wide poll of family doctors asking them to choose between the two options regarding extended hours put forward by the Government.
HYPERLINK "http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/health/7250589.stm" Should doctors be 'agents of the state'?
BBC Online Mon, 18 Feb 2008: quote by Tony Calland
Fresh from its success in getting GPs to work longer hours, the government has its eyes on extending the remit of doctors.
HYPERLINK "http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/health/7243304.stm" Doctors' leaders under the cosh
BBC Online Thu, 14 Feb 2008: quote by Richard Vautrey
The government was widely interpreted to have won a rare victory against doctors after GPs agreed not to oppose the plans for extended hours last week.
GPs back down on surgery opening hours
The Times Sat, 09 Feb 2008: quote by Laurence Buckman
The British Medical Association said the contract on offer was less damaging than an alternative that the Government had threatened to impose.
HYPERLINK "http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/politics/article3337971.ece" http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/politics/article3337971.ece
HYPERLINK "http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/health/7235596.stm" Doctors leaders' hours climbdown
BBC Online Fri, 08 Feb 2008: quote by Laurence Buckman
Doctors leaders have backed down in a dispute with the government over extending GPs opening hours. The British Medical Association has said the contract on offer is "less damaging" than an alternative the government had threatened to impose.
HYPERLINK "http://www.gm.tv/news/headlines/2008-02-08t195133z_01_l08816416_rtridst_0_ouktp-uk-britain-doctors.html" GPs in "impossible position" over longer hours
GMTV Fri, 08 Feb 2008: quote by Laurence Buckman
The government is threatening to take money away from GPs and give it to local health authorities unless they agree to open their practices an extra three hours a week from April.
HYPERLINK "http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/health/7232566.stm" GP poll blow to extra hours plan
BBC Online Thu, 07 Feb 2008: quote by Laurence Buckman
Ministers want GPs to work for longer. Nearly two-thirds of GPs in England will turn down the government's plan for a longer working week, a survey suggests.
HYPERLINK "http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/england/manchester/7229889.stm" BMA fails to represent doctors
BBC Online Wed 6 Feb 2008: quote Hamish Meldrum
The editor of the Lancet medical journal has launched a public attack on the British Medical Association.
HYPERLINK "http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/uk/health/article3304105.ece?token=null&offset=0" Health Secretary tells GPs they must open surgeries out of office hours
The Times Tue, 05 Feb 2008:
The Government clashed with doctors leaders today over negotiations to extend surgery opening hours, insisting that it was not "unreasonable to expect to see GPs at the evenings and weekends.
HYPERLINK "http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/health/7226350.stm" GPs respond to surgery hours plan
BBC Online Tue, 05 Feb 2008:
Dr TIM KIMBER: The government claiming that the BMA doesn't represent doctors is divide and rule, it's nonsense. I sit on the local medical committee in my area, and I see a lot of email traffic about what people are thinking and all GP's are opposed to the government's agenda. What you're seeing is an attack on the profession, and central control freakery.
HYPERLINK "http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/health/7223245.stm" Ministers target GPs over hours
BBC Online Mon, 04 Feb 2008: quote by Laurence Buckman
GPs and ministers are at loggerheads over extended hours Health Secretary Alan Johnson is writing to every GP in England urging them to accept the government's plans for extended surgery opening hours.
HYPERLINK "http://www.channel4.com/news/articles/society/health/johnson+writes+to+gps+over+ops+row/1474062" Johnson writes to GPs over ops row
Channel 4 News Mon, 04 Feb 2008: quote by Laurence Buckman
Health Secretary Alan Johnson has written to every GP in England to explain why he wants surgeries to open at evenings and weekends, it has been reported.
HYPERLINK "http://commentisfree.guardian.co.uk/richard_smith/2008/02/gps_versus_the_government.html" Richard Smith: Physician, heal thyself
The Guardian - Mon, 04 Feb 2008:
GPs have negotiated themselves very favourable contracts, and they aren't about to give in to demands to work longer hours
Regional GP coverage February 2008
Total 439
Print 190
Broadcast 249
Top Stories
Extended hours329NAO report 46Incapacity benefit42Polyclinics13Supermarkets3Vocation2Private2OoHs1Contract1IT1
BMA Spokesmen
SpokesmanTVRPLaurence Buckman6447John Canning1184Richard Vautrey3128George Rae141Kailash Chand373Grant Ingram10Chaand Nagpaul127Bob Morley17Stuart Scott16Peter Holden4David Bailey3Dean Marshall3Satya Sharma3Russell Walshaw3Douglas Colville2Tom Frewin11Simon Poole2Fay Wilson2David Baker1Roger Bully1Prit Buttar1John Cormack1Peter Fellowes1Vasco Fernandez1Roger Ford1Tony Hillier1Paul Hobday1Tom McKinstry1Hamish Meldrum1Adrian Midgeley1Nigel Watson1
Print
1/2
Worcester News Anger at plans for docs to work late P2
4/2
Scarborough News Johnson in longer GP hours appeal P8 Laurence Buckman quote
Sentinel GPs receive letters on hours increase P4 Laurence Buckman quote
Sheffield Star Extra hours for GPs P6
Halifax Evening Courier GPs could give more in return P12
Halifax Evening Courier Johnsons plea over GP hours P14 Laurence Buckman quote
Wolverhampton Express & Star Doctor hits out at letter plea on hours P7 Satya Sharma, Laurence Buckman quotes
Grimsby Telegraph Minister appeals to GPs by letter P6 Laurence Buckman quote
Lancashire Evening Post National extra P6 Laurence Buckman quote
Cumbria News & Star Row over GPs opening times P6 Chaand Nagpaul quote
North West Evening Telegraph Ministers and GPs clash over extra hours P4 Chaand Nagpaul quote
Northampton Chronicle Johnson in longer GP surgery hours plea P4 Laurence Buckman quote
Northants Evening Telegraph Johnsons appeal to GPs over hours P10 Laurence Buckman quote
Oldham evening Chronicle Clash over GP surgery hours P4 Chaand Nagpaul quote
Shields Gazette Extra GP hours battle heats up P8 Laurence Buckman quote
Portsmouth News GPs will quit if they are forced to work longer P4 Laurence Buckman quote
London Lite Minister goes to war with GPs on extended hours P5 Laurence Buckman quote
Manchester Evening News (3rd Ed) Ministers and GPs clash over weekend surgeries P4
Nottingham Evening Post Clash on more hours for GPs P8 Chaand Nagpaul quote
Huddersfield Daily Examiner Government plea to GPs over hours P8 Laurence Buckman quote
Newcastle Evening Chronicle Open all hours call to doctors P4 Chaand Nagpaul quote
Teeside Evening Gazette Clash over docs hours P6 Chaand Nagpaul quote
Chester Evening Leader Johnsons appeal to GPs on longer hours P4 Laurence Buckman quote
Peterborough Telegraph Johnsons appeal to GPs over hours P4 Laurence Buckman quote
Hartlepool Mail GPs urged: work longer P10 Laurence Buckman quote
Birmingham mail Call for GPs to open at night P4 Laurence Buckman quote
Colchester Gazette Stand-off over extra hours for surgeries P8 Laurence Buckman quote
Dorset Echo Health boss appeals to doctors by letter P2 Laurence Buckman quote
Shropshire Star GPs in wrangle over surgery bid P15
Leicester Mercury Government clash with doctors P2
Leicester Mercury Government and GPs clash over new hours P9 Laurence Buckman, Chaand Nagpaul quotes
Birmingham Post One size fits all plan may spark staffing crisis GPs P6 Bob Morley, Grant Ingrams quotes
5/2
Express & Echo (Exeter) Public deserves more convenient opening hours from our GPs P8
Birmingham Post Sorry, Doctor cant see you, hes too busy going home P10
Eastern Daily Press Doctors leaders wary of appointments plans P5 Laurence Buckman quote
Newcastle Journal Minister in clash over GP hours P6 Laurence Buckman quote
London Metro Ministers target GPs in fight over longer hours P21 Laurence Buckman quote
Bradford Telegraph & Argus Minister clashes with GPs on hours P6 Laurence Buckman quote
Northants Evening Telegraph Patients could pay price for longer surgery hours P7
Yorkshire Post Patients deserve flexible services P10
Western Morning News (Devon) Row over surgery opening hours P15
Western Morning News (Cornwall) Row over surgery opening hours P15
Brighton Argus Clash over plan to extend GPs hours P4 Laurence Buckman quote
The Press (York) Open all hours? P12
Bolton news New hours plan a disgrace, says GP P6
Cambridge News Lansley attacks bid to extend GP hours P9 Simon Poole quote
Coventry Telegraph Longer hours bid infuriates doctors P11 Grant Ingrams quote
East Anglian Daily Times (East Ed) Access to GPs a priority P8 Laurence Buckman quote
East Anglian Daily Times (Essex Ed) Access to GPs a priority P8 Laurence Buckman quote
East Anglian Daily Times (West Ed) Access to GPs a priority P8 Laurence Buckman quote
Huddersfield Daily Examiner Open all hours P6
Huddersfield Daily Examiner Why we wont have to be so patient waiting to see a GP P9 Laurence Buckman quote
Lancashire Telegraph GPs blast later opening hours P11
Lincolnshire Echo Open surgeries longer, minister urges doctors P5 David Baker quote
Manchester Evening News (1st & 2nd Eds) Row over surgery hours P17 Laurence Buckman quote
Cumbria News & Star Longer surgery hours wont help the patients P4
Darlington Northern Echo Ministers in stand off with GPs over hours P7 Laurence Buckman, John Canning quote
Durham Northern Echo Ministers in stand off with GPs over hours P7 Laurence Buckman, John Canning quote
Plymouth Herald GPs furious at changes P13
6/2
Express & Echo (Exeter) Government beliefs havent led to better service for patients P12 Adran Midgley quote
Burton Mail Cornerstone of Health P4
Burton Mail Patients will suffer warn GPs leaders P4
Bournemouth Daily Echo GPs leaders hit out at government bid P13 Tom McKinstry quote
Worcester News Extended GP hours: ministers are trying to bully us P5
Bromsgrove Advertiser Doctors protest at plans to extend their surgery time p1 Grant Ingrams quote
Oldham Evening Chronicle Most GPs willing to open longer Chand P23 Kailash Chand quote
Birmingham Post More cash needed if doctors are expected to extend hours P2 Bob Morley quote
7/2
Kettering Citizen Surgeries to open all week P8
Wolverhampton Express & Star Majority of GPs to reject hours move P27 Bob Morley quote
Huddersfield Daily Examiner GPs reject longer working P8
Manchester Evening News Two thirds of GPs will say no to extra hours P21 Bob Morley quote
Shropshire Star County GPs reject longer hours move P7
Yorkshire Post GPs defend their stance P12 Richard Vautrey quote
Yorkshire Post Comment and Letters P12
Lancashire Evening Post Doctors blast surgery open all hours plans P6 Richard Vautrey, Bob Morley quotes
Manchester Evening News Two thirds of GPs will say no to extra hours Bob Morley quote
The Forester GPs call on Lords for talks on surgery hours P11 Laurence Buckman quote
Worcester Journal GP at crisis meeting over bullying tactics P9
Coventry Observer Heavy criticism for new GP plans P5 Grant Ingrams quote
Halifax Evening Courier Lets talk on GPs hours P12
London Metro GPs would revolt over extra hours P5 Laurence Buckman quote
Dartford and Swanley Times GP fury P4
Eastern Daily Press Most GPs to reject extra hours plans P6 Bob Morley quote
8/2
Kent Messenger GP slams plans for longer hours P6 Paul Hobday quote
Northants Evening Telegraph Prescription for a healthy future P6
Eastern Daily Press GPs seeking best policy for patients P29
Western Daily Press Revolution at the doctors surgery? P12 Laurence Buckman quote
Darlington Echo Patients are not just targets P14 John Canning quote
Durham Echo Patients are not just targets P14 John Canning quote
Redditch Standard GPs voice fears over extended hours plan P11
Redditch Standard Doctors meet over hours bid P13 Grant Ingrams quote
Rutland Mercury GPs warning over longer hours plan P10
Sentinel Treat GPs in this way and patients will suffer most P10
Slough Observer Doctor calls for extra hours cash P6
Stamford Mercury GPs warning over longer hours plans P10
Sutton Coldfield News in favour of GP surgery hours plan P21
Wakefield express GPs fear NHS privatisation P18
Workington Times What about an open all hours service from family doctors? Its not necessarily what patients want P4
Peterborough Evening Telegraph Virgin on privatisation P14. Simon Poole quote
9/2
Express & Echo (Exeter) GPs in hours climb down P10
Shropshire Star GPs back down in pay dispute P5
Wolverhampton Express & Star Deal is in lesser of evils, say GPs P6
Wolverhampton Express & Star Doctors keen to have say on hours P11 Satya Sharma quote
Sentinel GPs cave in on opening P4
Lincs. echo GPs agree to surgeries opening rethink P6 Laurence Buckman quote
Oxford Mail GP hits back over hours row P7 Prit Buttar quote
Bolton News Doctors back down in extra hours row P4 Laurence Buckman quote
Cumbria News & Star GP working hours P12
Lancashire telegraph Lesser of two evils for GPs P4
Eastern Daily Press Doctors back down P7
Leicester Mercury Climbdown over opening hours for GPs P9
Liverpool Daily Post BMA makes deal over GP opening hours P2
Western Daily Press GPs give in to longer hours P2
Western Morning News Doctors back down P26
Yorkshire Evening Post Doctors despair P7 Richard Vautrey quote
Yorkshire Post GPs back down in battle over opening hours P2 Laurence Buckman quote
11/2
Heartland Evening News Evening surgery? P1
Worcester News General practice is being undermined P6
12/2
Wolverhampton Express & Star MP says GPs should give longer hours P25
Yorkshire Post Longer hours will be unsafe for GPs P6 Richard Vautrey quote
Ipswich Evening Star GPs debate hours P17
13/2
Leek paper Housecall P9
Hunts Post Pressure on GPs to extend hours P5 Laurence Buckman quote
14/2
Rugby Observer Doctors pressured to accept new deal P9
Teeside Evening Gazette Patient care is a priority P24
Worcester News Extended Hours P7
15/2
Newcastle Chronicle Should health be Virgin territory? P6 Roger Ford quote
Borehamwood Times Longer GP working hours are criticised P7
Ipswich Star Docs angry over hours P13 Laurence Buckman quote
16/2
Sheffield Star Days of family GP over warning P6
Grimsby Telegraph One stop clinics are the future P6
Yorkshire Post Battle that is still to come for GPs P12
19/2
Northants Eve Telegraph Its not broken so dont mend it P9
Wolverhampton Express & Star Vote on surgery hours change P5
Shropshire Star Extension of hours to be discussed in poll of GPs P14 Laurence Buckman quote
Birmingham Post GP changes would reduce patient choice P11
Worcester News Centre plan may be part of NHS hive-off P6
20/2
Shropshire star Move to sign off sick note culture P4 Peter Holden quote
Oldham Evening Chronicle Surgery hours plan upsets GPs P21 Kailash Chand quote
Havering Gazette End is nigh for Saturday clinics P10
Brentwood Gazette End is nigh for Saturday clinics P10
Liverpool daily Post GPs ballot P4
Metro London Doctors balloted on anti-social hours P4 Laurence Buckman quote
Newcastle Journal Surgery hours ballot P2
21/2
Eastern Daily Press Dr Johnsons got just the cure for incapacity P8
City Am Health secretary calls on GPs to help end sick-note culture P7
Bristol Post Its time to give out well-notes P14 Peter Holden quote
East Anglian Daily Times (Essex Ed.) Labour aiming to scale back benefit safety net P10 Peter Holden quote
Western Daily Press Doctors: Dont blame us for sick note culture P11 Tom Frewin quote
Glossop Chronicle Service for4 patients P12
Warrington Guardian Super surgery plan is revived P13 Richard Vautrey quote
Manchester Eve News (1st, 2nd & 3rd eds) Superstore GP is great step forward P8
Derbyshire Times High Peak has pioneered GP polyclinic idea P15
Wanstead Guardian Superclinics not the right way say GPs P8 Richard Vautrey quote
Camden New Journal A healthy debate P17
Shropshire Star GPs talks with MP over opening hours P21
Western Daily Press Be open about opening hours MP warns GPs P22 Laurence Buckman quote
Bromley Times Top medics condemn Darzi polyclinic plan P5 Richard Vautrey quote
Oldham Advertiser GPs join forces against changes P15
Birmingham Post Work-health balance on Labour agenda P12 John Canning quote
22/2
Sunderland Echo Support for sick note culture P13 George Rae quote
Oldham Evening Chronicle Doctor criticises role in sick note system P11 Kailash Chand quote
Rossendale Free Press Talks on extra hours for medics P17
23/2
New Milton Advertiser Letters P22
Cumberland and Westmorland Gazette Longer surgery hours examined P2 Laurence Buckman quote
Rochdale Observer GP anger at plan for longer hours P7
25/2
Hull Daily Mail Warning over GP calls P5
Yorkshire Evening Post Let doctors decide their own hours P10 Richard Vautrey quote
Peterborough Telegraph Support for sick note crackdown P30 Peter Holden quote
27/2
Worcester News GPs to vote on shambolic deal P5
Stroud News Private care by the back door P22
Warwickshire Telegraph Angry GPs deliver damning verdict on the Government P4 Grant Ingrams quote
Nuneaton Telegraph Angry GPs deliver damning verdict on the Government P4 Grant Ingrams quote
Coventry Telegraph Angry GPs deliver damning verdict on the Government P4 Grant Ingrams quote
28/2
Eastern Daily Press GP contract poor deal for taxpayers P29 Laurence Buckman quote
Newcastle Journal Bitter pill on new GP deal P6
Dartford Times GPs forced to accept opening hour changes P22 Laurence Buckman quote
Gravesend Reporter Docs forced to stay open P22 Laurence Buckman quote
Wolverhampton Express & Star GP wages soar 58pc but work hours down P6 Laurence Buckman quote
Wolverhampton Express & Star Contract has made service better claim P6 Satya Sharma quote
London Lite GPs get 60% rise for doing less work P2
29/2
Swandlicote Times the practice of medicine is a vocation and not a get rish quick job P9
Southport Visiter Back your local GPP14
Ashby Times The practice of medicine is a vocation and not a get rich quick job P9
Sutton Coldfield Observer A pity government prioritises less needy P13 Bob Morley quote
Nuneaton Telegraph GPs to march against clinics shake-up P1,2 Grant Ingrams quote
Warwickshire Telegraph GPs to march against clinics shake-up P1,2 Grant Ingrams quote
Broadcast
4/2
BBC Radio Berkshire Extended Hoursx3
BBC Radio Berkshire Extended Hours Laurence Buckman interview
BBC Radio Bristol Extended Hours Laurence Buckman interview
BBC Radio Bristol Extended Hours Tom Frewin interview
BBC Radio Bristol Extended Hours
BBC Radio Cornwall Extended Hours Laurence Buckman, Andy Stewart interviews
BBC Radio Cumbria Extended Hoursx3
BBC Radio Cumbria Extended Hours Laurence Buckman interview
BBC Radio Derby Extended Hours
BBC Radio Derby Extended Hours Laurence Buckman interview
BBC Radio Devon Extended Hours Laurence Buckman interview x2
BBC Radio Devon Extended Hours
BBC Radio Essex Extended Hours Laurence Buckman interview
BBC Radio Essex Extended Hours x3
BBC Radio Gloucester Extended Hours
BBC Radio Hereford Extended Hours Laurence Buckman interview
BBC Radio Humberside Extended Hours Laurence Buckman interview
BBC Radio Humberside Extended Hours
BBC Radio Kent Extended Hours x5
BBC Radio Kent Extended Hours Laurence Buckman interview
BBC Radio Leeds Fluoride
BBC Radio Leeds Extended Hours
BBC Radio Leeds Extended Hours Laurence Buckman interview
BBC Radio Leeds Extended Hours Richard Vautrey interview
BBC Radio Leicester Extended Hours Laurence Buckman interview
BBC Radio Lincs Extended Hours Laurence Buckman interview
BBC Radio Manchester Extended Hours
BBC Radio Manchester Extended Hours Laurence Buckman interview
BBC Radio Merseyside Extended Hours x2
BBC Radio Newcastle Extended Hours Laurence Buckman interview
BBC Radio Newcastle Extended Hours Richard Vautrey interview x2
BBC Radio Newcastle Extended Hours George Rae interview x4
BBC Radio Norfolk Extended Hours Laurence Buckman interview
BBC Radio Northants Extended Hours
BBC Radio Northants Extended Hours Laurence Buckman interview
BBC Radio Northants Extended Hours Tony Hillier interview
BBC Radio Nottingham Extended Hoursx3
BBC Radio Nottingham Extended Hours Richard Vautrey, Laurence Buckman interview
BBC Radio Solent Extended Hours Laurence Buckman interview
BBC Radio Somerset Sound Extended Hours Laurence Buckman interview
BBC Radio Somerset Sound Extended Hours Roger Bully interview
BBC Radio Suffolk Extended Hours
BBC Radio Sheffield Extended Hours Laurence Buckman interview x2
BBC Southern Counties Radio Extended Hours
BBC Southern Counties Radio Extended Hours Laurence Buckman interview x3
BBC Radio Shropshire Extended Hours Laurence Buckman interview x3
BBC Radio Stoke Extended Hours x2
BBC Radio Suffolk Extended Hours Laurence Buckman interview
BBC Radio Swindon Extended Hours
BBC Radio Swindon Extended Hours Laurence Buckman interview x2
BBC Radio Tees Extended Hours
BBC Radio Tees Extended Hours Laurence Buckman x2
BBC Radio Tees Extended Hours Laurence Buckman, John Canning interview
BBC Radio Tees Extended Hours John Canning interview
BBC Radio Three Counties Extended Hours
BBC Radio Three Counties Extended Hours Laurence Buckman interview
BBC Radio WM Extended Hours Fay Wilson interview
BBC Radio WM Extended Hours Bob Morley interview
BBC Radio Wiltshire Extended Hours
BBC Radio York Extended Hours
BBC Radio York Extended Hours Laurence Buckman interview x2
BBC Radio York Extended Hours Chaand Nagpaul interview x2
Aire FM Extended Hours Richard Vautrey interview
City FM (Liverpool) Extended Hours
Essex FM Extended Hours
Heart FM Extended Hours
LBC News 1152 AM Extended Hours x2
KM FM Folkestone Extended Hours
KM FM Thanet Extended Hours
Lanarkshire FM Extended Hoursx2
Metro FM Tyne and Wear Extended Hours George Rae interview
SGRI Ipswich FM Extended Hours
Silk FM Extended Hours
Smooth Radio East Extended Hours x2
Spire FM Extended Hours
Stray FM Extended Hours
Wave 105.2 Extended Hours Nigel Watson interview
West Sound Extended Hours
ITV Carlton GMTV Extended Hours x3
ITV Carlton News Extended Hours Kailash Chand interview x3
ITV Carlton Extended Hours Richard Vautrey interview x2
ITV Tyne Tees Extended Hours John Canning interview
5/2
BBC Radio Leicester Extended Hours Richard Vautrey interview
Classic FM Extended Hours
8/2
BBC Radio Coventry
BBC Radio Leeds Extended Hours
BBC Radio Devon Extended Hours
BBC Radio Northants Extended Hours
BBC Radio Stoke Extended Hours
BBC Radio Wilts Extended Hours
9/2
ITV Carlton Extended Hours Chaand Nagpaul interview
10/2
BBC Radio Gloucester Extended Hours
BBC Radio Lincs. Extended Hours
16/2
BBC Radio Leeds Polyclinics Richard Vautrey interview x2
Home 107.9 FM Polyclinics Richard Vautrey interview
19/2
Broadland Extended Hours x2
Century FM Extended Hours George Rae interview
Century 105 FM Extended Hours Kailash Chand interview x2
Galaxy North east Extended Hours
Heart FM Extended Hours
Imagine FM Extended Hours Kailash Chand interview
KM FM Extended Hours
QFM Extended hours x2
Real Radio FM (Cardiff) Extended Hours David Bailey interview
Real Radio Scot FM Extended Hours Dean Marshall interview
Real Radio Scot FM (Edinburgh) Extended Hours
Rugby FM Extended Hours
Signal One (Staffs/Cheshire) Extended Hours Kailash Chand interview
Smooth Radio (Glasgow) Extended Hours
Smooth Radio (Glasgow) Extended Hours Kailash Chand interview
Smooth Radio (Nottingham) Extended Hours
Smooth Radio (Birmingham) Extended Hours Fay Wilson interview
Smooth Radio (Birmingham) Extended Hours Kailash Chand interview
Talksport Extended Hours
Touch FM Extended Hours
Wish FM Extended Hours x2
Wolf FM Extended Hours Kailash Chand interview
20/2
BBC Radio Cornwall Sick Note John Canning interview x2
BBC Radio Derby Sick Note
BBC Radio Essex Sick Note John Cormack interview
BBC Radio Essex Sick Note John Canning interview
BBC Radio Lancashire Sick Note John Canning interview
BBC Radio Leicester Sick Note John Canning interview
BBC Radio Lincs Sick Note Russel Walshaw interview x3
BBC Radio Kent Sick Note John Canning interview
BBC Radio Newcastle Sick Note John Canning interview
BBC Radio Norfolk Sick Note John Canning interview x2
BBC Radio Northamton Sick Note John Canning interview
BBC Radio Nottingham Sick Note John Canning interview
BBC Three Counties Sick Note Vasco Fernandez interview
BBC Radio Scotland Extended Hours
BBC Radio Scotland Sick Note Stuart Scott interview x6
BBC Radio Tees Sick Note John Canning interview x2
BBC Radio Wilts Sick Note John Canning interview x2
Durham FM Sick Note Richard Vautrey interview
QFM Extended Hours x2
Reading 107 Sick Note Richard Vautrey interview
Real Radio Extended hours Hamish Meldrum interview
Real Radio Scot FM Extended Hours Dean Marshall interview
Smooth Radio (Glasgow) Extended Hours Dean Marshall interview
ITV Carlton Sick Note Richard Vautrey interview
ITV Carlton Sick Note
STV Central Extended Hours Douglas Colville interview x2
22/2
BBC Radio Coventry & Warks Out of Hours Grant Ingrams interview
26/2
BBC Radio Stoke Extended Hours
28/2
BBC Radio Cambridge NAO report Laurence Buckman interview
BBC Radio Cornwall NAO report Laurence Buckman interview x2
BBC Radio Devon NAO report Laurence Buckman interview
BBC Radio Essex NAO report
BBC Radio Essex NAO report Laurence Buckman interview
BBC Radio Gloucester NAO report Peter Fellowes interview
BBC Radio Hereford BBC NAO report Laurence Buckman interview
BBC Radio Humberside NAO report
BBC Radio Kent NAO report
BBC Radio Leeds NAO report Laurence Buckman interview
BBC Radio Lincolnshire NAO report Laurence Buckman interview
BBC Radio London NAO report Laurence Buckman interview
BBC Radio Merseyside NAO report Laurence Buckman interview
BBC Radio Newcastle NAO report
BBC Radio Newcastle NAO report George Rae interview x5
BBC Radio Newcastle NAO report Laurence Buckman interview x4
BBC Radio Norfolk NAO report Laurence Buckman interview
BBC Radio Northampton NAO report Laurence Buckman interview
BBC Radio Oxford NAO report Laurence Buckman interview x3
BBC Radio Sheffield NAO report Laurence Buckman interview x2
BBC Radio Solent NAO report Laurence Buckman interview x2
BBC Radio Somerset Sound NAO report
BBC Radio Swindon NAO report Laurence Buckman interview
BBC Radio Tees NAO report Laurence Buckman interview
BBC Radio Wales Incapacity benefit David Bailey interview x2
BBC Radio Wiltshire NAO report Laurence Buckman interview x2
BBC Radio York NAO report Laurence Buckman interview x2
Century FM 100.7 NAO report John Canning interview
Magic 1152 Tyne & Wear NAO report George Rae interview
29/2
Moray Firth FM Extended Hours
BBC Radio Scotland Extended Hoursx2
BBC Radio Scotland Extended Hours Stewart Scott interview
BBC1 Scotland Extended Hoursx2
Northern Ireland
No adverse GP coverage in NI local media during the past month, except for one article picked up by the Belfast Telegraph from the Press Association on the PAC GMS report for England
Northern Ireland had very positive proactive coverage on the GP poll - Belfast Telegraph and News letter (regional coverage won't be in until next week but should also be positive).
A GP interview has been set up with the Belfast Telegraph to be published early in April. It will focus on "The whole new world of modern General Practice" - a journalist is spending the day with Dr Colin Hegan's practice in Glengormley, Belfast.
Scotland
Press Releases:
6 March BMA Scotland announces GP poll results (Dean Marshall)
21 Feb Direct elections to NHS Boards will not improve public engagement, says BMA Scotland (Dean Marshall)
21 Feb BMA Scotland calls for tougher action on alcohol misuse (Andrew Thomson)
Broadcast:
6 March
GP Poll Results:
Real Radio News Dean Marshall & Andrew Buist
Radio Forth FM Dean Marshall
Talk 107 Andrew Buist & Stuart Scott
Central FM Stuart Scott
Wave 102 Andrew Buist
BBC Radio Scotland Live Andrew Buist
BBC Radio Scotland at 10 Dean Marshall
STV (Scotland Today) News Dean Marshall
BBC (Reporting Scotland) Dean Marshall
BBC Newsnight Scotland Dean Marshall
21 February: BBC West Midlands Radio Dr Andrew Thomson
Alcohol Misuse
BBC Armed Forces Radio Dr Andrew Thomson
Alcohol Misuse
20 February STV News
Extended Hours Dr Douglas Colville
Articles/Features:
Letters:
The BMA Scotland press office produced a media toolkit to help LMCs generate media coverage on extended hours and to encourage individual GPs to write to the local and national press.
The Press Office also offered advice on draft letters and LMC news releases. This resulted in local publicity for local doctors and focussed the debate forward (almost daily) on letters pages of the national press.
Articles:
4 March
The Scotsman (Medical Matters)
HYPERLINK "http://news.scotsman.com/health/Open-all-hours-Not-if.3838341.jp" Open all hours? Not if you want a better service. (Regular monthly article by Dr John Garner)
22 February
The Herald
HYPERLINK "http://www.theherald.co.uk/features/featuresopinon/display.var.2064433.0.Golden_opportunity_was_missed_on_GP_opening_hours.php" Comment Piece by Dr Dean Marshall (SGPC) Golden opportunity was missed on GP opening hours.
5 February
The Scotsman (Medical Matters)
GPs have plenty to teach these NHS managers. (Regular monthly article by Dr John Garner)
Comment/quotes/statements given on the following subject areas:
Prescribing Valium
Alcohol misuse
Organ Donation
Sick Notes
GP Extended Hours
GP pay/Contract
Sunbed Regulation
Parliamentary
From BMA Parliamentary Unit, London : GPC political activities
Meetings
Dr. Richard Vautrey met Jon Trickett MP (Secretary of the Parliamentary Labour Party's Health Committee) on Wednesday 12th March to discuss the future of general practice. Dr. Vautrey is also scheduled to meet John Grogan MP, who chairs the PLP Health Committee, later on this month to discuss a range of primary care issues.
Lobbying MPs on extended hours and the future of general practice
To date, more than 300 GPs have used an online system, which enables them to write to their MP through the BMA website. The Parliamentary Unit continues to encourage grassroots doctors to contact their MPs about the future of general practice.
Public Accounts Committee inquiry on the GP contract
The Parliamentary Unit is liasing with GPC to produce a briefing paper for the Public Accounts Committee ahead of its inquiry on the GP contract on Wednesday 26th March 2008. The Committee will hear evidence from David Nicholson, Chief Executive of the NHS. A number of GPC reps and local GPs have lobbied MPs on the Committee and the briefing paper will reinforce our position on the value of the GP contract.
Criminal Justice and Immigration Bill
The Criminal Justice and Immigration Bill contains proposals to make it an offence to cause nuisance behaviour on NHS hospital premises. The Bill is currently in Committee in House of the Lords and the BMA has been seeking an amendment so that the proposals extend to other premises where medical treatment is provided to the public by NHS staff members (e.g. GP surgeries). There was debate on the BMA's amendment during the Committee Stage this week. There was prominent mention of the BMA during the debate, although the Minister still did not accept that it was necessary to extend the provisions to settings outside of hospitals. The issue may be debated again at Lords Report Stage, which could be after Easter.
17 March 2008
PAGE
PAGE 21
Appendix 3
' , - . e f s t T U b *
+
m
ѳѣvivYvIv h{\ h: CJ OJ QJ \] h{\ h_ CJ OJ QJ \] ht CJ OJ QJ \] h{\ h\Vs CJ OJ QJ \] ht 5CJ OJ QJ ] h{\ h{\ 5CJ OJ QJ ] h{\ h\Vs 5CJ OJ QJ ] h7b h\Vs 5CJ OJ QJ hM[ h\Vs 5>*CJ OJ QJ h\Vs 5>*CJ OJ QJ h h\Vs 5>*CJ OJ QJ "h h\Vs 5>*CJ OJ QJ aJ . Z e f s t
> t V
`^``gd\Vs gd\Vs
$ dh a$ gd\Vs $ x x a$ gd_ $ a$ gd:
$dh a$gd\Vs $a$gd\Vs %
) * ] ^ ӶӦoaQFQ8 h}xx h\Vs 5OJ QJ aJ h\Vs 5OJ QJ aJ h1$ h\Vs CJ OJ QJ \aJ h1$ h\Vs 5OJ QJ aJ h1$ h\Vs 5CJ OJ QJ aJ h1$ h\Vs 5\ h\Vs h\Vs 5CJ OJ QJ h h\Vs 5CJ OJ QJ hU h\Vs CJ OJ QJ \] h{\ h{\ CJ OJ QJ \] h>_ CJ OJ QJ \] h{\ h\Vs CJ OJ QJ \] h{\ h: CJ OJ QJ \] h* CJ OJ QJ \]
@ ) $ $If a$ gd\Vs l ! $If gd\Vs l ! gd\Vs ) * 1 E ^ K 1 $ $If ` a$ gd\Vs l ! $If gd\Vs l ! kd $$If l \ +2"
t 0 6 4 4
l a E Q ] ^ e x 5 kd $$If l \ +2"
t 0 6 4 4
l a $If gd\Vs l ! $ $If a$ gd\Vs l ! H 5 5 $If gd\Vs l ! kd $$If l \ +2"
t 0 6 4 4
l a $ $If a$ gd\Vs l ! + , Z [ P Q ' ( I K L O P S a c d g h k m n ֹzmzmzmzmzmzmzmz h\Vs 5CJ OJ QJ aJ h h\Vs 5CJ OJ QJ aJ "h h\Vs 5>*CJ OJ QJ aJ h\Vs 5>*CJ OJ QJ aJ h h\Vs 5CJ OJ QJ hO h\Vs CJ OJ QJ \aJ h\Vs CJ OJ QJ \aJ h\Vs 5OJ QJ aJ h}xx h\Vs 5OJ QJ aJ h1$ h\Vs CJ OJ QJ \aJ * + ^ K K 5 5 $ $If a$ gd\Vs l ! $If gd\Vs l ! kd $$If l \ +2"
t 0 6 4 4
l a + , 4 F Q Z ^ K K 5 5 $ $If a$ gd\Vs l ! $If gd\Vs l ! kd, $$If l \ +2"
t 0 6 4 4
l a Z [ c w } ^ K K 5 5 $ $If a$ gd\Vs l ! $If gd\Vs l ! kd $$If l \ +2"
t 0 6 4 4
l a ^ K K 5 5 $ $If a$ gd\Vs l ! $If gd\Vs l ! kdB $$If l \ +2"
t 0 6 4 4
l a ^ K K 5 5 $ $If a$ gd\Vs l ! $If gd\Vs l ! kd $$If l \ +2"
t 0 6 4 4
l a ^ K K 5 5 $ $If a$ gd\Vs l ! $If gd\Vs l ! kdX $$If l \ +2"
t 0 6 4 4
l a " 2 ; P ^ K K 5 5 $ $If a$ gd\Vs l ! $If gd\Vs l ! kd $$If l \ +2"
t 0 6 4 4
l a P Q Y k v ^ K K 5 5 $ $If a$ gd\Vs l ! $If gd\Vs l ! kdn $$If l \ +2"
t 0 6 4 4
l a ^ K K 5 5 $ $If a$ gd\Vs l ! $If gd\Vs l ! kd $$If l \ +2"
t 0 6 4 4
l a ^ K K 5 5 $ $If a$ gd\Vs l ! $If gd\Vs l ! kd $$If l \ +2"
t 0 6 4 4
l a ' ( ) ^ S K K K 8 $If gd\Vs l ӳ $a$gd\Vs
$ dh a$ gd\Vs kd $$If l \ +2"
t 0 6 4 4
l a ) 2 ; A B I F 3 $If gd\Vs l T kd $$If l \ h ) $ \ e
t 0 $6 4 4
l a $$If a$gd\Vs l ӳ I L P T U a F 3 $If gd\Vs l kd/ $$If l \ h ) $ \ e
t 0 $6 4 4
l a $$If a$gd\Vs l T a d h l m n o F A A gd\Vs kd $$If l \ h ) $ \ e
t 0 $6 4 4
l a $$If a$gd\Vs l o w F kdY $$If l =F
T
t 0 6 4 4
l a $ $If a$ gd\Vs l ' $If gd\Vs l ' ( ) * + , - . Q R S T U V W p q r s t u v | } ~ "h h\Vs 5>*CJ OJ QJ aJ h h\Vs CJ OJ QJ aJ h\Vs CJ OJ QJ aJ S Y C $ $If a$ gd\Vs l ' kd $$If l =F
T
t 0 6 4 4
l a $$If a$gd\Vs l ' o Y C C $$If a$gd\Vs l $ $If a$ gd\Vs l kdW
$$If l =F
T
t 0 6 4 4
l a o Y C C $$If a$gd\Vs l T $ $If a$ gd\Vs l T kd
$$If l =F
T
t 0 6 4 4
l a ) + - o Y C C $$If a$gd\Vs l $ $If a$ gd\Vs l kdU $$If l =F
T
t 0 6 4 4
l a - . R T V o Y C C $$If a$gd\Vs l $ $If a$ gd\Vs l kd $$If l =F
T
t 0 6 4 4
l a V W q s u o Y C C $$If a$gd\Vs l T $ $If a$ gd\Vs l T kdS $$If l =F
T
t 0 6 4 4
l a u v } o \ F F $$If a$gd\Vs l $If gd\Vs l kd $$If l =F
T
t 0 6 4 4
l a o \ F F $$If a$gd\Vs l $If gd\Vs l kdQ
$$If l =F
T
t 0 6 4 4
l a o Y C C $$If a$gd\Vs l ' $ $If a$ gd\Vs l T kd
$$If l =F
T
t 0 6 4 4
l a o Y C C $$If a$gd\Vs l ' $ $If a$ gd\Vs l T kdO $$If l =F
T
t 0 6 4 4
l a o Y C C $$If a$gd\Vs l ' $ $If a$ gd\Vs l T kd $$If l =F
T
t 0 6 4 4
l a " o \ F F $$If a$gd\Vs l T $If gd\Vs l T kdM $$If l =F
T
t 0 6 4 4
l a ! " # $ % F G W X Z [ ] _ n o q r s u h\Vs CJ OJ QJ aJ h h\Vs CJ OJ QJ aJ h\Vs 5>*CJ OJ QJ aJ h\Vs 5CJ OJ QJ aJ h h\Vs 5CJ OJ QJ aJ "h h\Vs 5>*CJ OJ QJ aJ B" # $ % 6 @ F o j j W A A $$If a$gd\Vs l ' $If gd\Vs l ' gd\Vs kd $$If l =F
T
t 0 6 4 4
l a F G X [ ^ o \ F F $$If a$gd\Vs l $If gd\Vs l kdK $$If l F y&
t 0 6 4 4
l a ^ _ o r t o \ F F $$If a$gd\Vs l \ $If gd\Vs l \ kd $$If l /F y&
t 0 6 4 4
l a t u o \ F F $$If a$gd\Vs l $If gd\Vs l kd- $$If l /F y&
t 0 6 4 4
l a o \ F F $$If a$gd\Vs l $If gd\Vs l kd $$If l /F y&
t 0 6 4 4
l a o \ F F $$If a$gd\Vs l \ $If gd\Vs l \ kd $$If l /F y&
t 0 6 4 4
l a o \ F F $$If a$gd\Vs l \ $If gd\Vs l \ kd $$If l /F y&
t 0 6 4 4
l a o \ F F $$If a$gd\Vs l \ $If gd\Vs l \ kd $$If l /F y&
t 0 6 4 4
l a o \ F F $$If a$gd\Vs l \ $If gd\Vs l \ kdb $$If l /F y&
t 0 6 4 4
l a o \ F F $$If a$gd\Vs l \ $If gd\Vs l \ kd $$If l /F y&
t 0 6 4 4
l a
o \ F F $$If a$gd\Vs l \ $If gd\Vs l \ kdD $$If l /F y&
t 0 6 4 4
l a $ & ' ) * + - 8 9 T n 8 S ` b | } 6 P Q ` "h h\Vs 5>*CJ OJ QJ aJ h h\Vs >*CJ OJ QJ aJ !hM[ h\Vs 56>*CJ OJ QJ h\Vs 56>*CJ OJ QJ aJ h\Vs 5CJ OJ QJ aJ h h\Vs 5CJ OJ QJ aJ h\Vs CJ OJ QJ aJ h h\Vs CJ OJ QJ aJ 4
o \ F F $$If a$gd\Vs l \ $If gd\Vs l \ kd $$If l /F y&
t 0 6 4 4
l a $ ' * o \ F F $$If a$gd\Vs l \ $If gd\Vs l \ kd& $$If l /F y&
t 0 6 4 4
l a * + , - 8 9 T U n o g g g g g g g g \ $
& F a$ gd\Vs $ a$ gd\Vs kd $$If l /F y&
t 0 6 4 4
l a
; W f o p $
& F a$ gd\Vs $
& F a$ gd\Vs $
& F a$ gd\Vs $ a$ gd\Vs $
& F a$ gd\Vs $ @ I Z [ p t u $
& F a$ gd\Vs $
& F a$ gd\Vs $
& F a$ gd\Vs $ a$ gd\Vs 0 7 8 S T ` v 3 4 I a b | } $
& F a$ gd\Vs $
& F a$ gd\Vs $ a$ gd\Vs 5 6 P Q ` u $ 7 H $
& F a$ gd\Vs $ a$ gd\Vs $
& F a$ gd\Vs $ I a : V t u v L ߲ߌveߌ h h\Vs 0J CJ OJ QJ aJ +j h h\Vs CJ OJ QJ UaJ %j h h\Vs CJ OJ QJ UaJ %h h\Vs 56>*CJ OJ QJ aJ !hM[ h\Vs 56>*CJ OJ QJ h\Vs CJ OJ QJ aJ h h\Vs 5CJ OJ QJ aJ h h\Vs CJ OJ QJ aJ "h h\Vs 5>*CJ OJ QJ aJ H I a v % * H Y ] t $
& F
a$ gd\Vs $
& F a$ gd\Vs $ a$ gd\Vs & 9 : V g { $
& F a$ gd\Vs $ a$ gd\Vs $
& F a$ gd\Vs L M N ] ^ 1 2 3 U V
! ! ?! @! ! ! ! ! ! ," 1" B" C" " ֶֶֶֶֶֶtֶdֶ h h\Vs 5CJ OJ QJ aJ +j> h h\Vs CJ OJ QJ UaJ +j[ h h\Vs CJ OJ QJ UaJ +j$ h h\Vs CJ OJ QJ UaJ h h\Vs CJ OJ QJ aJ h h\Vs 0J CJ OJ QJ aJ %j h h\Vs CJ OJ QJ UaJ +j
h h\Vs CJ OJ QJ UaJ s ! ,! ! +" ," 2" " o# p# v# # # # 3$ L$ v$ w$ }$ 4% % % % $
& F
a$ gd\Vs $
& F a$ gd\Vs $ a$ gd\Vs $
& F a$ gd\Vs " " " " " " " ># ?# @# m# n# p# u# # # w$ |$ $ $ $ $ $ % % % % % % & & & 7& 8& k& l& & ֶֶֶֶzֶֶdֶֶ +j h h\Vs CJ OJ QJ UaJ +jo h h\Vs CJ OJ QJ UaJ h h\Vs 5CJ OJ QJ aJ +jj h h\Vs CJ OJ QJ UaJ h h\Vs CJ OJ QJ aJ h h\Vs 0J CJ OJ QJ aJ %j h h\Vs CJ OJ QJ UaJ +je h h\Vs CJ OJ QJ UaJ $% T& ' >' ?' E' ' ' ( ,( v( ( ) \) x) ) &* '* -* * + + , $
& F a$ gd\Vs $
& F a$ gd\Vs $
& F a$ gd\Vs $
& F a$ gd\Vs $ a$ gd\Vs $
& F a$ gd\Vs & & & ' ' ?' D' '* ,* @* A* * * * * * * * _+ `+ a+ n+ o+ , , , 1, 2, , , , , , - - ֶֶֶֶzֶnֶXֶ +j# h h\Vs CJ OJ QJ UaJ h\Vs CJ OJ QJ aJ +j! h h\Vs CJ OJ QJ UaJ +j h h\Vs CJ OJ QJ UaJ h h\Vs 5CJ OJ QJ aJ h h\Vs CJ OJ QJ aJ h h\Vs 0J CJ OJ QJ aJ %j h h\Vs CJ OJ QJ UaJ +j h h\Vs CJ OJ QJ UaJ ", , , , - - - - - . . / j/ / / / / / / H0 0 0 0 0 $
& F a$ gd\Vs $
& F a$ gd\Vs $
& F a$ gd\Vs $ a$ gd\Vs - '- (- q- r- s- - - - - M. N. O. m. n. / / / / 0 0 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 [2 \2 ]2 u2 v2 u3 v3 94 {e +j' h h\Vs CJ OJ QJ UaJ +j=& h h\Vs CJ OJ QJ UaJ h h\Vs 5CJ OJ QJ aJ +j % h h\Vs CJ OJ QJ UaJ h h\Vs 0J CJ OJ QJ aJ +j$ h h\Vs CJ OJ QJ UaJ %j h h\Vs CJ OJ QJ UaJ h h\Vs CJ OJ QJ aJ '0 0 1 1 1 2 3 b3 4 H5 6 f6 6 w7 7 7 8 8 v9 9 9 : : ; $
& F a$ gd\Vs $
& F a$ gd\Vs $
& F a$ gd\Vs $ a$ gd\Vs $
& F a$ gd\Vs 94 :4 ;4 4 4 4 4 4 5 5 F5 G5 [5 \5 5 5 5 6 6 6 6 67 77 87 Y7 Z7 8 8 }8 ~8 8 8 8 8 8 F9 ֶֶֶֶֶֶtֶֶ^ֶֶ +j. h h\Vs CJ OJ QJ UaJ +j<- h h\Vs CJ OJ QJ UaJ +j+ h h\Vs CJ OJ QJ UaJ +j* h h\Vs CJ OJ QJ UaJ h h\Vs CJ OJ QJ aJ h h\Vs 0J CJ OJ QJ aJ %j h h\Vs CJ OJ QJ UaJ +j( h h\Vs CJ OJ QJ UaJ #F9 G9 H9 t9 u9 /: 0: : : : : : : : @; A; B; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; !< "< B< G< < < K= L= = ֶֶֶֶֶֶtֶddֶ h h\Vs 5CJ OJ QJ aJ +j2 h h\Vs CJ OJ QJ UaJ +j1 h h\Vs CJ OJ QJ UaJ +j0 h h\Vs CJ OJ QJ UaJ h h\Vs CJ OJ QJ aJ h h\Vs 0J CJ OJ QJ aJ %j h h\Vs CJ OJ QJ UaJ +j/ h h\Vs CJ OJ QJ UaJ ; $< A< B< < < < < 4= )> *> +> @> A> > > r? s? ? ? @ @ A 6A 7$ 8$ H$ gd\Vs $ 7$ 8$ H$ a$ gd\Vs $
& F a$ gd\Vs $ a$ gd\Vs $
& F a$ gd\Vs = = = = > )> *> +> @> A> B> }> ~> > > > > > s? ֶֶkQ<< )h h\Vs B*CJ OJ QJ ^J aJ ph 2h h\Vs 5>*B*CJ OJ QJ \^J aJ ph +j5 h h\Vs CJ OJ QJ UaJ /h h\Vs 5B*CJ OJ QJ \^J aJ ph !hM[ h\Vs 56>*CJ OJ QJ h\Vs CJ OJ QJ aJ h h\Vs CJ OJ QJ aJ h h\Vs 0J CJ OJ QJ aJ %j h h\Vs CJ OJ QJ UaJ +j3 h h\Vs CJ OJ QJ UaJ s? t? ? ? ? ? ? ? @ @ @ @ @ @ @ A A 6A {B |B Ѵтo`Joo`3 ,h h\Vs >*B*CJ OJ QJ ^J aJ ph +j6 h h\Vs CJ OJ QJ UaJ h h\Vs CJ OJ QJ aJ %j h h\Vs CJ OJ QJ UaJ /h h\Vs 5B*CJ OJ QJ \^J aJ ph 2h h\Vs 5>*B*CJ OJ QJ \^J aJ ph 8j5 h h\Vs B*CJ OJ QJ U^J aJ ph )h h\Vs B*CJ OJ QJ ^J aJ ph 2j h h\Vs B*CJ OJ QJ U^J aJ ph 6A {B |B B C C C !D XD D D ]E E F F pF F AG BG jG G 4H H H +I dI WJ XJ $ 7$ 8$ H$ a$ gd\Vs 7$ 8$ H$ gd\Vs |B }B B B B B B B C C C C C C C D D !D ͯhhUF0UUF +j}8 h h\Vs CJ OJ QJ UaJ h h\Vs CJ OJ QJ aJ %j h h\Vs CJ OJ QJ UaJ /h h\Vs 5B*CJ OJ QJ \^J aJ ph )h h\Vs B*CJ OJ QJ ^J aJ ph 2h h\Vs 5>*B*CJ OJ QJ \^J aJ ph ;j7 h h\Vs >*B*CJ OJ QJ U^J aJ ph ,h h\Vs >*B*CJ OJ QJ ^J aJ ph 5j h h\Vs >*B*CJ OJ QJ U^J aJ ph !D XD D D 1E 2E 3E [E \E E F F F KF LF MF Թ雹o\M7\ +j?: h h\Vs CJ OJ QJ UaJ h h\Vs CJ OJ QJ aJ %j h h\Vs CJ OJ QJ UaJ /h h\Vs 5B*CJ OJ QJ \^J aJ ph 'h h\Vs 0J 5CJ OJ QJ ^J aJ ;jr9 h h\Vs 5B*CJ OJ QJ U^J aJ ph 5j h h\Vs 5B*CJ OJ QJ U^J aJ ph )h h\Vs B*CJ OJ QJ ^J aJ ph ,h h\Vs 5B*CJ OJ QJ ^J aJ ph MF mF nF F AG BG iG G 3H 4H 5H H H H H H ӻw\w>\\ ;j ; h h\Vs >*B*CJ OJ QJ U^J aJ ph 5j h h\Vs >*B*CJ OJ QJ U^J aJ ph ,h h\Vs >*B*CJ OJ QJ ^J aJ ph /h h\Vs 5B*CJ OJ QJ \^J aJ ph )h h\Vs B*CJ OJ QJ ^J aJ ph /h h\Vs 5B*CJ OJ QJ \^J aJ ph %j h h\Vs CJ OJ QJ UaJ 2h h\Vs 5>*B*CJ OJ QJ \^J aJ ph H H H H I I I )I *I cI WJ XJ YJ J J J J J 2K K K K K %L &L ҿkҿUkҿ? +j> h h\Vs CJ OJ QJ UaJ +j< h h\Vs CJ OJ QJ UaJ )h h\Vs B*CJ OJ QJ ^J aJ ph 2h h\Vs 5>*B*CJ OJ QJ \^J aJ ph +j< h h\Vs CJ OJ QJ UaJ h h\Vs CJ OJ QJ aJ %j h h\Vs CJ OJ QJ UaJ /h h\Vs 5B*CJ OJ QJ \^J aJ ph )h h\Vs B*CJ OJ QJ ^J aJ ph XJ K 3K K K IL L M !M M M 'N (N N N O O P j> h h\Vs 5B*CJ OJ QJ U\^J aJ ph 8j h h\Vs 5B*CJ OJ QJ U\^J aJ ph /h h\Vs 5B*CJ OJ QJ \^J aJ ph )h h\Vs B*CJ OJ QJ ^J aJ ph 2h h\Vs 5>*B*CJ OJ QJ \^J aJ ph %j h h\Vs CJ OJ QJ UaJ 'N (N )N N N N N N N O O O O O P P
*B*CJ OJ QJ U^J aJ ph >j@ h h\Vs 5B*CJ OJ QJ U\^J aJ ph )h h\Vs B*CJ OJ QJ ^J aJ ph *h h\Vs 0J 5CJ OJ QJ \^J aJ >j? h h\Vs 5B*CJ OJ QJ U\^J aJ ph /h h\Vs 5B*CJ OJ QJ \^J aJ ph 8j h h\Vs 5B*CJ OJ QJ U\^J aJ ph )h\Vs 5B*CJ OJ QJ \^J aJ ph Q Q Q Q R R R *B*CJ OJ QJ U^J aJ ph /h h\Vs 5B*CJ OJ QJ \^J aJ ph )h h\Vs B*CJ OJ QJ ^J aJ ph 2h h\Vs 5>*B*CJ OJ QJ \^J aJ ph 5j h h\Vs >*B*CJ OJ QJ U^J aJ ph ;jA h h\Vs >*B*CJ OJ QJ U^J aJ ph ,h h\Vs >*B*CJ OJ QJ ^J aJ ph tT uT U (U U U U U U U U U U U U V V $ $If a$ gd\Vs l ' gd\Vs 7$ 8$ H$ gd\Vs $ 7$ 8$ H$ a$ gd\Vs uT vT T T T U U (U U U U U U U U ˫ˀnZJ;.J h\Vs 5CJ OJ QJ aJ hd h\Vs CJ OJ QJ aJ hd h\Vs 5CJ OJ QJ aJ 'h60 h\Vs 56;>*CJ OJ QJ ]#h\Vs B*CJ OJ QJ ^J aJ ph )h h\Vs B*CJ OJ QJ ^J aJ ph *h h\Vs 0J 5CJ OJ QJ \^J aJ >jC h h\Vs 5B*CJ OJ QJ U\^J aJ ph /h h\Vs 5B*CJ OJ QJ \^J aJ ph 8j h h\Vs 5B*CJ OJ QJ U\^J aJ ph V V V V n n $ $If a$ gd\Vs l z kdD $$If l 0
G
t 0 6 4 4
l a] V V 3V 6V n n $ $If a$ gd\Vs l z kd2E $$If l 0
G
t 0 6 4 4
l a] 6V 7V CV FV n n $ $If a$ gd\Vs l z kdE $$If l 0
G
t 0 6 4 4
l a] FV GV TV VV n n $ $If a$ gd\Vs l z kdE $$If l 0
G
t 0 6 4 4
l a] VV WV `V bV n n $ $If a$ gd\Vs l z kd^F $$If l 0
G
t 0 6 4 4
l a] bV cV kV mV n n $ $If a$ gd\Vs l z kdF $$If l 0
G
t 0 6 4 4
l a] mV nV sV uV n n $ $If a$ gd\Vs l z kd&G $$If l 0
G
t 0 6 4 4
l a] uV vV V V n n $ $If a$ gd\Vs l z kdG $$If l 0
G
t 0 6 4 4
l a] V V V V n n $ $If a$ gd\Vs l z kdG $$If l 0
G
t 0 6 4 4
l a] V V V V V V V V i i i i $ $If a$ gd\Vs l ' gd\Vs z kdRH $$If l 0
G
t 0 6 4 4
l a] U V V V V V X X X Y zY Y Y Y {Z Z Z [ ;[ Q[ ~[ [ [ [ *\ >\ \ \ \ \ /] C] x] ] ] ] ,^ B^ ]^ _^ ^ ^ )_ ?_ _ _ _ _ "` 8` x` ` ` ` a a ^a ta a a rb b b c м hd h\Vs CJ H*OJ QJ aJ h\Vs CJ OJ QJ aJ &hd h\Vs 5CJ OJ QJ \^J aJ hd h\Vs 5CJ OJ QJ aJ hd h\Vs CJ OJ QJ aJ hd h\Vs CJ OJ QJ ^J aJ ?V V V V V V \ F F F F $ $If a$ gd\Vs l kdH $$If l \ j V & &7 & &b
t 0 $6 4 4
l a V V V V V V ^ H H H H $ $If a$ gd\Vs l kdKI $$If l \ j V 7 b
t 0 $6 4 4
l a V V V V V V ^ H H H H $ $If a$ gd\Vs l kdI $$If l \ j V 7 b
t 0 $6 4 4
l a V V V V V W ^ H H H H $ $If a$ gd\Vs l kdaJ $$If l \ j V 7 b
t 0 $6 4 4
l a W W W W W W ^ H H H H $ $If a$ gd\Vs l kdJ $$If l \ j V 7 b
t 0 $6 4 4
l a W W #W $W %W (W ^ H H H H $ $If a$ gd\Vs l kdwK $$If l \ j V 7 b
t 0 $6 4 4
l a (W )W 8W :W W ^ H H H H $ $If a$ gd\Vs l kdL $$If l \ j V 7 b
t 0 $6 4 4
l a >W ?W JW KW MW OW ^ H H H H $ $If a$ gd\Vs l kdL $$If l \ j V 7 b
t 0 $6 4 4
l a OW PW ]W _W aW bW ^ H H H H $ $If a$ gd\Vs l kdM $$If l \ j V 7 b
t 0 $6 4 4
l a bW cW pW qW rW tW ^ H H H H $ $If a$ gd\Vs l kdM $$If l \ j V 7 b
t 0 $6 4 4
l a tW uW W W W W ^ H H H H $ $If a$ gd\Vs l kd.N $$If l \ j V 7 b
t 0 $6 4 4
l a W W W W W W ^ H H H H $ $If a$ gd\Vs l kdN $$If l \ j V 7 b
t 0 $6 4 4
l a W W W W W W ^ H H H H $ $If a$ gd\Vs l kdDO $$If l \ j V 7 b
t 0 $6 4 4
l a W W W W W W ^ H H H H $ $If a$ gd\Vs l kdO $$If l \ j V 7 b
t 0 $6 4 4
l a W W W W W W ^ H H H H $ $If a$ gd\Vs l kdZP $$If l \ j V 7 b
t 0 $6 4 4
l a W W W W W W ^ H H H H $ $If a$ gd\Vs l kdP $$If l \ j V 7 b
t 0 $6 4 4
l a W W W W W W ^ H H H H $ $If a$ gd\Vs l kdpQ $$If l \ j V 7 b
t 0 $6 4 4
l a W W X X X X ^ H H H H $ $If a$ gd\Vs l kdQ $$If l \ j V 7 b
t 0 $6 4 4
l a X X X X X X ^ H H H H $ $If a$ gd\Vs l kdR $$If l \ j V 7 b
t 0 $6 4 4
l a X X &X 'X )X *X ^ H H H H $ $If a$ gd\Vs l kdS $$If l \ j V 7 b
t 0 $6 4 4
l a *X +X 7X 8X 9X ;X ^ H H H H $ $If a$ gd\Vs l kdS $$If l \ j V 7 b
t 0 $6 4 4
l a ;X Y BY Y ^ Y Y Y Y Q Y I
& F) gd\Vs
& F+ gd\Vs gd\Vs kdY $$If l \ j V 7 b
t 0 $6 4 4
l a Y Y Z @Z Z [ R[ [ [ ?\ \ \ D] ] ] C^ ^ ^ @_ _ _ 9` ` ` a ua a a 3b
& F) gd\Vs 3b b c c c gc c d ]d d e de e e #f sf f f g mg g h vh h i Ni i j
& F' gd\Vs gd\Vs
& F) gd\Vs c c d Fd \d d d d e \f rf
g g Yg lg g g h h _h uh h i i i i i i i i j j j j k k k el xl m %m mm m m m ^n nn n o lo o o p ^p np p p Aq Tq q q >r Nr r r Xs ns s s s s nt t v v w w x *x Xx ix x x hd h\Vs CJ H*OJ QJ aJ hd h\Vs 5CJ OJ QJ aJ hd h\Vs CJ OJ QJ aJ Rj Gj j k Mk Qk k k !l yl l &m m m m n on n o ?o o o p op p q Uq q
& F& gd\Vs gd\Vs
& F' gd\Vs q q r Or Sr r r s os s s :t t t t 7u su u u ]v v v v w `w w w +x
& F% gd\Vs gd\Vs
& F& gd\Vs +x jx x x y Cy y y y z cz z z z ${ ){ r{ { { { | S| X| | |
& F" gd\Vs
& F# gd\Vs
& F$ gd\Vs
& F( gd\Vs gd\Vs
& F% gd\Vs x Mz bz z z { { <| R| .} >} } } 1 G N a 1 G > P ~ f { % ; x M ] h ) > | F Y ] s . D _ o Í ( P R h\Vs 5CJ OJ QJ aJ hd h\Vs CJ H*OJ QJ aJ hd h\Vs 5CJ OJ QJ aJ hd h\Vs CJ OJ QJ aJ M| | | ?} }} } } } -~ g~ l~ ~ ~ H b Ӏ H t u z
& F gd\Vs
& F gd\Vs
& F! gd\Vs gd\Vs
& F" gd\Vs z
Q F ( | < ƅ ^ "
& F gd\Vs
& F gd\Vs gd\Vs
& F gd\Vs ? ƈ Z t E 7 < p č (
& F, gd\Vs
& F* gd\Vs gd\Vs
& F gd\Vs ( , S ю , { ޏ ; z א ! ` Ǒ % @ a ؒ T z
& F gd\Vs gd\Vs R w Ў P z Ï ݏ : [ y E _
$ ג 9 S # I e Ɣ + E k Е 8 c } # ~ ߗ ' A C d z ϙ ; O hd h\Vs 5CJ OJ QJ aJ hd h\Vs CJ OJ QJ aJ Yz $ f F 9 ~ $ Q C f ǘ D {
& F gd\Vs P u Ӛ B g " _ ٜ & B g ޝ gd\Vs
& F gd\Vs Қ ( A ! J ^ % d f ݝ = V U m ޟ 0 Q S p 1 ^ ` š ܡ U l Ԣ + @ l ң գ + E ~ Ǥ ! 8 U p ť ܥ 7 N p 9 R o hd h\Vs CJ OJ QJ aJ hd h\Vs 5CJ OJ QJ aJ X W s w ͞ 4 8 n s 1 6 T 2 I a ݡ gd\Vs
& F gd\Vs ݡ
' m բ A ֣ F b Ȥ 9 q ݥ O
& F gd\Vs gd\Vs
& F gd\Vs S ҧ 9 u : ? & ^ { - O k
& F gd\Vs gd\Vs
& F gd\Vs o ϧ ѧ 8 ] t ͨ 9 i ͩ % C ] ժ , ǫ = W Ӭ * N h ƭ e ܮ
4 Q n ȯ ܯ % ' L c )hd h\Vs B*CJ OJ QJ ^J aJ ph hd h\Vs CJ OJ QJ aJ hd h\Vs 5CJ OJ QJ aJ M X y + i F 5 o ݯ ( d $ 7$ 8$ H$ a$ gd\Vs gd\Vs
& F gd\Vs Q ( ^ g ˳ Գ + , 2 C Լ}eNeNeNe}4}e 2h h 5B*CJ H*OJ QJ \^J aJ ph ,h h B*CJ OJ QJ \^J aJ ph /h h 5B*CJ OJ QJ \^J aJ ph /h h 5B*CJ OJ QJ \^J aJ ph .h h 5;B*CJ OJ QJ \^J ph h h\Vs CJ OJ QJ aJ /h h 5;B*CJ OJ QJ ^J aJ ph +h h\Vs 5;B*CJ OJ QJ ^J ph )h h\Vs B*CJ OJ QJ ^J aJ ph P Q _ ` ̳ ͳ ) * $
$7$ 8$ H$ ^`$a$ gd $ p7$ 8$ H$ ^p`a$ gd $ 7$ 8$ H$ a$ gd $
7$ 8$ H$ a$ gd gd\Vs $ 7$ 8$ H$ a$ gd\Vs * 2 C r Ӵ 7 8 a b $ 7$ 8$ H$ ^`a$ gd $ 7$ 8$ H$ a$ gd $ p7$ 8$ H$ ^pa$ gd $ 7$ 8$ H$ ^`a$ gd $
7$ 8$ H$ a$ gd $
$7$ 8$ H$ ^`$a$ gd C 7 8 a b 6 7 D u ' ( : Y 균qY?q 2h h 56B*CJ OJ QJ \^J aJ ph /h h 6B*CJ OJ QJ \^J aJ ph ,h h B*CJ OJ QJ \^J aJ ph /h h 5B*CJ OJ QJ \^J aJ ph ,h h B*CJ OJ QJ \^J aJ ph /h h 5B*CJ OJ QJ \^J aJ ph 5h h 56B*CJ OJ QJ \]^J aJ ph )h h B*CJ OJ QJ ^J aJ ph ' 6 7 M t u L M ' ( 2 : Y
$
7$ 8$ H$ a$ gd $
$7$ 8$ H$ ^`$a$ gd $ 7$ 8$ H$ ^`a$ gd $ 7$ 8$ H$ a$ gd Y Z ڸ ۸
% & u`O7` /j[ h h CJ OJ QJ U^J aJ h h CJ OJ QJ ^J aJ )j h h CJ OJ QJ U^J aJ ,h h B*CJ OJ QJ \^J aJ ph #h h 5CJ OJ QJ ^J aJ h CJ OJ QJ ^J aJ h h CJ OJ QJ ^J aJ 2j Z h h CJ OJ QJ U\^J aJ #h h CJ OJ QJ \^J aJ ,j h h CJ OJ QJ U\^J aJ % > غ & 6 H I J X $ 7$ 8$ H$ a$ gd\Vs $
& F- 7$ 8$ H$ a$ gd $ 7$ 8$ H$ a$ gd $
$7$ 8$ H$ ^`$a$ gd $
7$ 8$ H$ a$ gd > غ H I J X ǵǞo`N9! .h h\Vs 5;B*CJ OJ QJ \^J ph )h h B*CJ OJ QJ ^J aJ ph #h B*CJ OJ QJ ^J aJ ph h h CJ OJ QJ aJ ,h h 5B*CJ OJ QJ ^J aJ ph /h h 5B*CJ OJ QJ \^J aJ ph ,h h B*CJ OJ QJ \^J aJ ph #h h 5CJ OJ QJ ^J aJ h h CJ OJ QJ ^J aJ )j h h CJ OJ QJ U^J aJ #h h CJ OJ QJ \^J aJ X + U
ѼѼѼѤqgaga]gagRga] he 0J mH nH uh&
h& 0J j h& 0J U h h_ CJ OJ QJ aJ h h\Vs CJ OJ QJ aJ )h h\Vs B*CJ OJ QJ ^J aJ ph /h hgb 5B*CJ OJ QJ \^J aJ ph )h h\Vs B*CJ OJ QJ ^J aJ ph /h h\Vs 5B*CJ OJ QJ \^J aJ ph +h h\Vs 5B*CJ OJ QJ \^J ph + U
# $