ࡱ> lnk @ bjbj w zzz8T )j(LI(((((((($v*R,(R"RR( ( RR( R( :#&,& *"azjO& /'\(0 )Y&R- d-&-&q^ SLqqq((zr Rz SHAPE \* MERGEFORMAT  REVALIDATION FOR GENERAL PRACTITIONERS CONSULTATION RESPONSE FORM Please fill out the response form below and return it to the Royal College of General Practitioners by Closing Date: Friday 9 January 2009 The Questions below are also embedded within the consultation document itself Please use either this form or the online response form to provide your feedback. Responses should be sent to  HYPERLINK "mailto:responses@rcgp.org.uk" responses@rcgp.org.uk Returned by Fax: 0207 589 3145 By Post The Honorary Secretary Revalidation Consultation Policy and Governance Royal College of General Practitioners 14 Princes Gate London SW7 1PU Please fill out your details Name: Address: Email: Are you a GP?: If so what type of GP do you consider yourself: (e.g. GP Principal, Sessional, salaried, academic GP, GP trainer, other etc.): General Comments: SECTION 1: The standard process for the revalidation of general practitioners Principles Consultation question 1. Have you any comments on the principles identified? Are any unclear, or are there any that have been missed?ANSWER: The evidence to be gathered Consultation question 2. Have you any comments on the areas of evidence to be gathered? Are any of the areas particularly challenging to gather, and if so, how?ANSWER: Consultation question 3. Have you any comments? Are there any particular areas that you think need to be considered when developing an electronic portfolio? Assessment of evidence for revalidation Consultation question 4. Have you any comments about the local arrangements described and those at the national level?ANSWER: Quality Assurance Consultation question 5. Have you any suggestions about how the RCGP should satisfy the GMC that the process is fair, equitable and objective?ANSWER: SECTION 2: Non-standard processes for the revalidation of general practitioners Consultation question 6. Are then any other areas that could be considered non-standard? If so, what are they and do they fall within the guidance defined in the paper?ANSWER: Issues to be considered The minimum clinical commitment required to establish eligibility for a recommendation for recertification Consultation question 7. Bearing in mind that the RCGP will need to consult on this in the future, do you feel that the example is about right?ANSWER: The acceptability of evidence from GPs not working in approved settings Consultation question 8. Do you feel this is the correct level for acceptability of evidence?ANSWER: The extent to which GPs in active clinical practice can choose what evidence to provide Consultation question 9. Do you feel that this provision is flexible enough?ANSWER: The revalidation of GPs who wish to return to clinical practice Consultation question 10. Have you any comments on the process put forward for those returning to clinical practice?ANSWER: The revalidation of GPs working as doctors but not in clinical general practice Consultation question 11. Have you any comments?ANSWER: Portfolios for revalidation for general practitioners Consultation question 12. Do you think that these definitions capture all the possible permutations?ANSWER: APPENDIX 1: The map of the RCGPs Criteria to the Domains and Attributes in the General Medical Councils Framework The map to the General Medical Councils Framework Consultation question 13. Have you any comments about the mapping to the GMCs Framework shown in the table below?ANSWER: APPENDIX 2: Criteria, Standards and Evidence for the revalidation of general practitioners Consultation question 14. We would welcome your comments on the criteria, standards and evidence set out in the table below. In particular, we welcome your views on: The overall proposals Their balance and fitness for purpose Comments on the specific sections of the document (appendix 2)ANSWER: Royal College of General Practitioners December 2008     0Tabcdj 穕}ylbXbHb>bhZAOJQJ^Jh$h$5>*OJQJ^Jh@1YOJQJ^Jh$OJQJ^Jh;+h;+OJQJ^Jh$hp|z&h>5B*CJ OJQJ^JaJ ph&h3W5B*CJ OJQJ^JaJ ph,hX( h3W5B*CJ OJQJ^JaJ ph!jhjRh3WOJQJU^J*jh3WOJQJU^JmHnHsH uh3WOJQJ^Jjh3WOJQJU^JFGbcd?    3 N d gd3W$a$gd3W       3 N qfYLBBh@1YOJQJ^JhZAhZAOJQJ^Jh@1Yh@1YOJQJ^Jh$>*OJQJ^JhZAhZA>*OJQJ^JhZA>*OJQJ^Jh;+h$OJQJ^JhZAhZA5OJQJ^JhZAOJQJ^Jh$OJQJ^Jh$h$0J5OJQJ^J*jh$h$5OJQJU^Jh$h$5OJQJ^J$jh$h$5OJQJU^J t u v w x y @&gdk6&$d%d&d'dNOPQgd$&$d%d&d'dNOPQgd@1Y  " L c j o r t u v w x y 񻱤}sfbN&hk65B*CJOJQJ^JaJphh@1Yh$h$OJQJ^Jh$OJQJ^Jh$h@1Y5OJQJ^Jh$5OJQJ^Jh$h$5OJQJ^Jh$h@1YOJQJ^Jh>cOJQJ^Jh@1YOJQJ^Jh#_5OJQJ^Jh/(5OJQJ^Jh5OJQJ^Jh@1Y5OJQJ^Jh@1Yh@1Y5OJQJ^J q s { | } ~  Ѿ~seaN>hk65B*OJQJ^Jph$h'hk65B*OJQJ^Jphh$h>h@1Y5OJQJ^Jhk65OJQJ^Jh>h>5OJQJ^Jh)OJQJ^Jh&'h)5OJQJ^Jh$OJQJ^Jh)5B*OJQJ^Jph$hk6hk65B*OJQJ^Jphhk6&hk65B*CJOJQJ^JaJph,h[Uhk65B*CJOJQJ^JaJph r s | } ~ qJJ&$d%d&d'dNOPQgd>}kd$$Ifl# $  t 0644 l` ap $Ifgd?lIgd)~  @ A I J pII&$d%d&d'dNOPQgd>}kd$$Ifl# $  t 0644 l` ap $Ifgd?lI@&gd> ? @ A H I J K Y _ a b #)+,Ҳujf\h>cOJQJ^Jhk6h>5OJQJ^Jh$OJQJ^Jh)5B*OJQJ^Jph$hEhk65B*OJQJ^Jphhk65B*OJQJ^Jphh$h>h@1Y5OJQJ^Jh>h>5OJQJ^Jh)OJQJ^Jh>OJQJ^Jh&'h)5OJQJ^Jh)5OJQJ^J$J K sqkk@&gd>}kdm$$Ifl# $  t 0644 l` ap $Ifgd?lIgd)<ZZXRRI $Ifgd?lI@&gd>&$d%d&d'dNOPQgd>}kd$$Ifl# $  t 0644 l` ap ;=DEFGHs~CELMNOghlxxn[nMBhk65OJQJ^JhR\hk65OJQJ^J$hbhk65B*OJQJ^Jphhk6OJQJ^Jh)5OJQJ^Jh$OJQJ^J,h[Uhk65B*CJOJQJ^JaJph&hk65B*CJOJQJ^JaJphh>hk6h>h@1Y5OJQJ^Jh>5OJQJ^Jh>h>5OJQJ^Jh)OJQJ^Jh&'h)5OJQJ^J<=EFGHZZXXPP$@&gd>c&$d%d&d'dNOPQgd>}kdW$$Ifl# $  t 0644 l` ap DEMNOghvOOME?$gd>c$@&gd>c&$d%d&d'dNOPQgd>}kd$$Ifl# $  t 0644 l` ap $$Ifgd>chefnopiBB@&$d%d&d'dNOPQgd>}kdA$$Ifl# $  t 0644 l` ap $Ifgd?lIgd G $ & Fgd>cdfmnop !"$|}-/ƸƸƍƸƸh $hk65OJQJ^JhR\hk65OJQJ^Jhk6h>h@1Y5OJQJ^Jh>5OJQJ^Jh>h>5OJQJ^Jhk6OJQJ^Jhk65OJQJ^Jh&'hk65OJQJ^Jh$OJQJ^Jh$hk6OJQJ^J-p!"#kDD?gdk6&$d%d&d'dNOPQgd>}kd$$Ifl# $  t 0644 l` ap $Ifgd?lIgd$ & Fgdk6#$|}kDD&$d%d&d'dNOPQgd>}kd+$$Ifl# $  t 0644 l` ap $Ifgd?lI & Fgdk6gdk6kDD&$d%d&d'dNOPQgd>}kd$$Ifl# $  t 0644 l` ap $Ifgd?lI & Fgdk6gdk6$%kDD&$d%d&d'dNOPQgd>}kd$$Ifl# $  t 0644 l` ap $Ifgd?lI & Fgdk6gdk6#$%&'+,]^tvyEܝzvr^&hk65B*CJOJQJ^JaJphh$hk6hk65B*OJQJ^Jph$hBhk65B*OJQJ^Jphh$OJQJ^Jh>h@1Y5OJQJ^Jh>5OJQJ^Jh>h>5OJQJ^Jh&'hk65OJQJ^Jhk6OJQJ^Jhk65OJQJ^JhLghk65OJQJ^J%&']^mFF&$d%d&d'dNOPQgd>}kd$$Ifl# $  t 0644 l` ap $Ifgd?lI@&gdk6gdk6DExyZ}kd$$Ifl# $  t 0644 l` ap $Ifgd?lI@&gd$$@&gd>c$gd>c$@&gd>cEIxyRTjlnxźźŰkźŰ`RGRhZA5OJQJ^Jh$h$5OJQJ^Jh@1Y5OJQJ^J&hk65B*CJOJQJ^JaJphh>OJQJ^Jh>h@1Y5OJQJ^Jh>5OJQJ^Jh>h>5OJQJ^Jhk6OJQJ^Jhk65OJQJ^Jh&'hk65OJQJ^Jh$OJQJ^Jhk65B*OJQJ^Jph$hd>hk65B*OJQJ^JphST8w & F$Ifgd?lI $Ifgd?lI@&gd$gdk6&$d%d&d'dNOPQgd> wxZZXXXXXXX&$d%d&d'dNOPQgd>}kdt$$Ifl# $  t 0644 l` ap h$h$5OJQJ^JhjhU .&P 1F:p>c. A!"#$%Fk%4"!U]YǕJFIFC     C  V" }!1AQa"q2#BR$3br %&'()*456789:CDEFGHIJSTUVWXYZcdefghijstuvwxyz w!1AQaq"2B #3Rbr $4%&'()*56789:CDEFGHIJSTUVWXYZcdefghijstuvwxyz ?@__O9x<-4cRJabBbU[-__sBX4q^K5ɥf<<iwt?]G F?<Yc?[Zo  ˨ 9x-)pddhK(|}kmq fK\f{#- r<!Vw F?<+?lxk_&>n4/7:};;)aqYzUY")$$낰R2/)ە~' inc' ߵNJ4;F{B!}H{2=K >)|t6k_d'ou x\8O"T2ݕw~W-gx?{/e4!ǂt |OihZLl% D?!άQԂ#kv=gqG$?MTܛvݯ39VWf(=(((((((((((Nz) GWpkfX؁~C?ܾh ޵?To—SH܁4GN%ʩ/!Pϋ>6Gu=+W-kYjVкS*AGR~:[u^_@P*3.Ex~#Q1[ڤqȪNB6pXgajQrJ>vL,. |C6~Ծ"Ҭ>#@}NjK-IEaz(d߅`o q j,uៃvme}mYpVWE(0*2O$cॗ~lATrgcjT@wͺtH㿊*ď:1Q.idcܳ{/  |YCf}O7q!y/gg"7ʤ d 94WЩIӔSV!5({w7|g:i?}BD1{"U\^"## lgelWyeB?%|WǓJ=36"OGOs_e~xODփxMҮu%G7i*WЌs_ÿş ᮑl0Я/Z[]nhU6V b+K?rj-i,>Ct9m@p$pAsXC,3Uxx~KO9tGtwXypʲ4Nv_N9awkZ4ϠVQk駦WրAnwĿ/{þ+~!M?Z? Iay<6n"qEH%F71<0~_MGGc&_o CT:}G{yۆM(bm_To?/RkMcɯ3MtM*O j B#oc ;)'?^)/#|]ú]5Z[![{ܱy3ReB5:f#:M8S};$*4z/|OY\^x7p XX퀦m[zw {t }u|(_&T2< {5_6m4ū[[++ygqOԉJ6OhsƯ3~0LO|;q4R +pNp==OJ |ix2;K%_jT,湶f qHi@lW|o #؋=C|Iu~/ug=ꍍ%U ¹J-4I/[+dShMٿ~Tc95rWsoc<R:v:om K(|^M;,#F7;H~$꺏7|طJ >}"}/]|m)u0sOKIZ\Y?g,?,koc¿hxUυ~M) T6ۣx&ݷ#&ocђW_ sdqT2Q]%3&mQg_g!ivw )#,NO*[;O#~|R^^,"=^k牷G2\;U?v@c\'QŚ7_߳Oiofuη+KVvX7v#0S!b ?x<qCS!N?ez寂^! z5KUy!P;8b³+oW d灵9录mk 1mT,H_#(c-<+>$AH kB?綍8;m]_Rkz}?2)Z_(Qا #Զ|/ouw .]lK/w޿፥.67uxO.3slC3|#uaXӿf_zg4Oҿ4m^]bI6RZ6` +d1Q87i?<@W{ #D[| M ʯ Tu qU5oگ/uk+tćV[I4YHEpX) Ri~imG;[G__xMM?R73ܮjcHnRWd 8k |1Ҿ ? >-Jk(u kNᤛK9&{L*662||-OoYNx+*,g_0Z?jO>4-gU-}meop#p@ Q 2b)U9Wgv$7~h_?G:f{? M]Yj;AK)q ̲VA[/*оk|%Yeoq4Y+[G#[)1W)?> -|qp-NHI'0pm^<,?nٶflG4_GqK`FU;UU9 Mk;[[^){vZ\? >|\?-kCwݰR3E!+"e=/7iеR!c]_j7_[eq$fp~|o?>+;v:|9ZKz"[fj|ɺ7p _kB7ǿ:Gah"5޻&$[}q&$CS쫨I_]m7~'|=}O~ Km?FҭM72J !*P?=pUҗVu;c^iyt DW%2I`\AW5?ۯM4׋m1f˿8"g?*n#5>BHˎ4}cý I.Uƛ^@9(Wy+),d+_&K|ym&Ч7E1#AB096QQ1H-=`\ךihZ_wfoi=eo4˷y]GTS$ץ!TsĚeEPP9Rab+?ƿ9Rab+8CF:s/ g_'(#& _K<QaʅoWNWS4H夑ؖf'$zk Qh`\xEc%w6({L~d9GR8 AʦsJI۶VnOǖ>]o.iWzeܶ6HUu9VV]/Bs$1oZmu٭"C"¬q>2|N3DOVg+&Kiڄv~r*A?+9? w9#4OiiZ<`%]Q@ngWUlD#‹jW$խ0|5{?\j|'/uKܼD`'o$oxڷ߃~!>/bO#uPCE2:8k>&>ϋ~?4|S^_ kZM>M.UB\3Z:~~C÷z||ydOk4V`Y0 ]UHžGzbQWd&>~M1׼/c#KNS-f̈́I$z{4ml|@7<7=70>&ot^:}͍ 2ֳCr9ckH涾ǭ=~(k~)l|wxa7w=ų3aX0gDƿឣ~,៎tJ|)Gyc$ao@ʹOاp:v7bdgҫO/_όK|hk&4oPkJWL[隅ۧomh~ВT(.vW3hLx!M?Zu ]Ŷo+ IlC~4wbIE- xtw_?~'|">|B┞8|YhzͦV+ﴤ[Zsk,;#.E ~z>x7~=dAƺֵqj7؋;׷`ϻpXU 1ɣ9Trm|8u~#gqg[x_IJ{ xUKh;ws*'х µWV1[umE u_s>xE4q_$z8f?c⏅?O/lmGþJNY ˸23_IU!K5曲{:儴UGq(ӧ|o/0ܮmFձ[̟Č^@`A״w?S5 jxr ttKlh1$*Կ_7*gԯQFvZ;ih,Daxf]G[~~,-oWK4(t 4M;4S\;XV$ ^iT~Կm77vjo3>U`"*UIcjOakKQ 1mў|U{tWʢkek%&QJ<6I}sv e'ŏ[k[O?o$I#d.CjvE~~6:Ֆ7 F'@,[\FyI>*Կ_7X [7'v{UukIhckw=f| W 1mў|U{?g? < >aX5['2CH_ka)I?{gҜ+5ꏢ((((((((((((O*?ʏ*/ʊ)ݙYGE]*D?*<(#_-??*Z(; (QEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEDd D  3 @@"?DyK responses@rcgp.org.ukyK Rmailto:responses@rcgp.org.ukyX;H,]ą'c%s$$If!vh5 $#v $:Vl  t 65 $` p s$$If!vh5 $#v $:Vl  t 65 $` p s$$If!vh5 $#v $:Vl  t 65 $` p s$$If!vh5 $#v $:Vl  t 65 $` p s$$If!vh5 $#v $:Vl  t 65 $` p s$$If!vh5 $#v $:Vl  t 65 $` p s$$If!vh5 $#v $:Vl  t 65 $` p s$$If!vh5 $#v $:Vl  t 65 $` p s$$If!vh5 $#v $:Vl  t 65 $` p s$$If!vh5 $#v $:Vl  t 65 $` p s$$If!vh5 $#v $:Vl  t 65 $` p s$$If!vh5 $#v $:Vl  t 65 $` p s$$If!vh5 $#v $:Vl  t 65 $` p s$$If!vh5 $#v $:Vl  t 65 $` p @@@ k6NormalCJ_HaJmH sH tH DA@D Default Paragraph FontVi@V  Table Normal :V 44 la (k(No List 8 @8 Footer  9r CJ8@8 Header  9r CJj@j k6 Table Grid7:V0P"P k6 Footnote TextdCJOJPJQJaJ@&1@ k6Footnote ReferenceH*6U@A6 $ Hyperlink >*B*ph RFGbcd?3Ndtuvwxyrs|}~@AIJK<=EFGHDEMNOghe f n o p   ! " # $ | }     $ % & ' ] ^ D E x y ST8wx000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000x0x0x0x0x0x0 0 00 0 0 00x0 0 00 00 0 000x0 0 00x0x000 0 00x0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0x0x0x0Ox 0Ox0Ox0O 0O 0O0O0Ox 0O0O0O 0O 0O0Ox0Ox0O  0O 0O 0O 0O 0O 0O0O 0Ox0Ox0O 0O 0O0O0O  0O0 0 0 00 0 0x0 0x0 0 00x0x0x0x0x0x00 0 00x000x0 00 0 0 0 0 00x0x00x@00B2@00$@0@00@   E !$' ~ J <hp#%w  "#%&(_Xl,R$4"!U]YǕs%0R@,(    A&??&"LJ RCGP colour newPicture 20LJ RCGP colour newC"?B S  ? t _Toc215885927 _Toc215885930 _Toc215885932 _Toc215885934 _Toc215885937 _Toc215885938 _Toc215885939 _Toc215885941 _Toc215885942HO' E f\ C w R bŽ7 Î4 ĎT< Ŏ7 Ǝ`ǎ>< Ȏddjiqq9*urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:smarttagsplace8*urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:smarttagsCity=*urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:smarttags PlaceName=*urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:smarttags PlaceType8 *urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:smarttagsdate 120099DayMonthYear pq33"cjttwwA2_)8Nvgjg@h^`OJQJo(hHh^`OJQJ^Jo(hHohpp^p`OJQJo(hHh@ @ ^@ `OJQJo(hHh^`OJQJ^Jo(hHoh^`OJQJo(hHh^`OJQJo(hHh^`OJQJ^Jo(hHohPP^P`OJQJo(hHh hh^h`hH)h 88^8`hH.h L^`LhH.h   ^ `hH.h   ^ `hH.h xLx^x`LhH.h HH^H`hH.h ^`hH.h L^`LhH.vgA2_                  i)|(%/(;+ W314k68A G?lIXS3W@1Y#_>cp|zZAGT;$>rs@AK<=DEe f   }    ^ y Twx@@UnknownGz Times New Roman5Symbol3& z Arial7&{ @Calibri?5 z Courier New;Wingdings"1hÓ̆œ̆*̦X` X` !$x4d2qHP ?k6MSECTION 1: The standard process for the revalidation of general practitioners Saqib Ahmad Karen Day  Oh+'0$0@ T` |   PSECTION 1: The standard process for the revalidation of general practitioners Saqib AhmadNormal Karen Day3Microsoft Word 10.0@Ik@"V@!a@61!aX` ՜.+,D՜.+,|8 hp  RCGP NSECTION 1: The standard process for the revalidation of general practitioners Title 8@ _PID_HLINKSAtzmailto:responses@rcgp.org.uk  !"#$%&'()*+,-./0123456789:;=>?@ABCEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ\]^_`abdefghijmRoot Entry F"aoData <1TableD-WordDocumentwSummaryInformation([DocumentSummaryInformation8cCompObjj  FMicrosoft Word Document MSWordDocWord.Document.89q